Bennington Tobacconist, founded in 1965 by William E. Bennington, is a family-operated tobacco shop located in Saint Armand's Circle, Sarasota, Florida. The business has been passed down to the founder's three sons, Jack, Jim, and Gary, who have learned the values of service, quality, and hard work. Bennington Tobacconist is known for its custom hand-mixed tobacco blends and hand-rolled cigars, as well as its friendly and knowledgeable staff. Customers praise the shop's great selection, solid business practices, and amazing family atmosphere. Whether you're an experienced cigar enthusiast or a newcomer, the staff at Bennington Tobacconist are happy to provide personalized recommendations and assistance, ensuring a pleasant shopping experience.
Jack was very professional and knowledgeable. Dan was very pleased with all recommendations for cigars and pipe tobacco. Always great service and always enjoy our annual in-person visit. Thanks for your expertise Jack.
January 2026
I have enjoyed coming to this store for the past several years. The owner and employees are all very nice and they have a great selection. Very professional.
September 2025
This store was truly one of a kind. Not many stores like this left. Clean store and great selection. The gentleman working who appeared to be the owner was very knowledgeable and offered impeccable customer service. Definitely recommend if you’re in the area and looking for a good cigar
