-
October 2023 by Positivity Podcast
Very delicious cookies! I really enjoyed all their decadent and over the top flavors. I actually tried Great American cookie while on a business trip in Atlanta and was delighted to see that they're also in the UTC mall. I discovered the other location on Too Good To Go and I would really love to see y'all on Too Good To Go as well! It's a great app that allows store like Great American Cookie at UTC sell their unsold cookies for a discount! 99 Bottles in downtown Sarasota are already on it and I truly love the app. I'd love to see you guys on there too! Overall, truly delicious cookies and great customer service! :)
-
May 2023 by Kim Gordon
Amazing cookie personally made for my son and future daughter in law’s engagement party! This definitely exceeded my expectations! Not to mention the professionalism from the first call to pick-up!
-
May 2023 by John McDowell
Love double doozies but don’t need the double cookie cals. Came in yesterday and bought a single cookie and had frosting on top of it. Paid with credit card. Came back today and woman forced me to pay $5 minimum so was forced to buy the double doozie. 1st world problems, but inconsistent service to save a few cents on cc fees. Good reason for me to stop going and avoid the calories ?
-
May 2023 by Lindsie Coleman
Owners are so sweet and cookies are yum!
-
December 2022 by Alissa Albritton
Super yummy Cookie Cake! I got it for my son’s birthday party. Turned out great. Everyone loved it! I especially loved it. And that following week ordered another just for us to have at home! ?Really good price as well. Thanks guys! I know for sure we will be back ??
-
December 2022 by No Way
Great cookies, right by the play area in the mall. Kids adore this place
-
November 2022 by Paul C.
I'm not impressed with the taste of the chocolate chip cookies and they claim to be made fresh every day which these didn't seem to be freshly made, I bought and ate the cookies right after they opened for the day.
-
September 2022 by Ben V
Great cookies and very delicious! Friendly staff.Don't listen to Victoria Singer, you can tell she is affiliated with another cookie company. Read her other reviews.
-
August 2022 by victoria singer
never personally bought these cookies, but my friend brought me some to try, they were DISGUSTING!!! we were throwing up in the bathroom 2 minutes later. very sweet and not flavorful. go to clarabell cookies if u want some delicious, perfectly made cookies!!
-
June 2022 by Ward R.
I needed a cookie cake for a bachelorette party and the great American cookie company came in clutch! I had emailed a couple of local bakeries and none were very helpful. The lady who helped me was so friendly and working alone and still made it happen in 15 mins.
-
April 2022 by Ann T.
These are the best cookies in Sarasota. My son and I come here every time we are at the mall and truly enjoy the sugar cookies. The walnut raisin cookie is also delicious.
-
October 2021 by Evan Guthrie
This Great American Cookies location at University Town Center in Sarasota is a great place to get cookies and treats while shopping. I like that they have warm cookies available here and everything is well prepared and tastes good. Good experience coming here and happy with my purchases.
-
August 2021 by SouthFloriDUDE
They have amazing cookies with so much variety! There cookies are amazing and I recommend anyone to try one out!
-
August 2021 by Brenda Garcia
LOVE THIS PLACE TO BITS WISH THEY HAD MORE LOCATIONS!! ???❤❤ SO WORTH THE MONEY
-
July 2021 by Mikah G
We did not receive the item we ordered. We have been coming here for years and this is by far the worst cookie we received. The whole thing was not fully iced, as requested. As well as there was no color on the happy birthday. We called and the lady was not friendly until the end. It was frustrating to receive this for a special birthday.
