Olde City Jewelry & Pawn in St. Augustine, FL, is the premier pawn shop serving surrounding areas since 2008. They specialize in fine jewelry, coins, firearms, and vintage watches. Customers describe it as a nice, friendly place with a great staff and great customer service. Reviews highlight a knowledgeable, professional, and helpful team that provides amazing service. Many report positive experiences selling items, getting loans, and buying jewelry, including wedding bands, diamond earrings, and watches. The business is noted for offering good value, with one customer receiving twice as much as elsewhere. Visitors and locals consistently recommend it as a place to do business with good people.
Very reasonable prices and the entire staff are very kind
May 2026
Came here to sell gold and the people behind the counter were very friendly and helpful. They tested the gold correctly and paid me a fair price in cash for my gold. Excellent service!
April 2026
Great experience at this local family business. Transparent process to evaluate the things I brought in. Very satisfied.
