“Anthony was extremely knowledgeable and was a pleasure to work with. Thanks to him, we have a one of a kind piece that we will cherish for years to come. If you’re in his area, definitely stop in.”
“Came in for a repair on a bracelet and they were able to help me in house and had it fixed within 10 minutes! Would definitely recommend to anyone super friendly and knowledgeable staff!”
“Mandy at Kay Jewelers provided great service. She was personable, helpful, and made the experience easy and comfortable. I would definitely go back to her for any future jewelry purchases.”
“Emily S. helped us choose a gift for our granddaughter. Emily was soooo helpful and patient. She was VERY knowledgeable about the jewelry. Because of Emily, I will return to Kay for my next gift purchase.”
“Have ordered several times now & always experience above & beyond excellent customer service & personal attention to details from both Brian & Kyle. Nothing but good things to say about their company. Items are always as described, if not better. Delivery is always prompt. Look forward to continue doing business!”
“It was special to get a beautiful chain to complement my anchor charm. Also. The chain was customized for the size and an unexpected design made the whole experience worthwhile. Thanks, Megan and the boss!”
“This is hidden “gem” of a jewelry store in St. Augustine! I have purchased several unique pieces from Frank and even had a custom piece done as well. The service of the staff is amazing - I will be going back again!”
“Came here to sell gold and the people behind the counter were very friendly and helpful. They tested the gold correctly and paid me a fair price in cash for my gold. Excellent service!”
“Visited this museum/shop this past September. A very interesting place full of nautical relics and treasure. I had the pleasure of meeting Marc, he is an ocean of knowledge. Of course I bought some of the lesser priced coins. Definitely a must go to place.”
“**This review is on behalf of my very good New Brunswick, Canada friends Jean-Claude & Nicole LeBlanc**
I'm from Canada and I am very fussy and picky with my jewlery, I was in St. Augustine when I needed a repair on one of my jewlery
when someone recommended this local store in the heart of downtown.
I brought in my jewlery that needed repairs and jewlery i wanted to upgrade with better quality. The owner of the store, Mr.Myers, customized my pieces so beautifully and professionally exactly as I wanted that I was impressed very much.
I wanted to thank Mr. Myers for such fine work you did at such a reasonable price.
Thank you again.
Don't hesitate to bring in jewlery for repairs or uprades, he's the best.
sincerely Nicole LeBlanc
New Brunswick, Canada.”
“We had such a nice time here today and gor 3 beautiful pearls. The lady that helped us was so kind and sweet and shared so much information with us. She took her time and made it such a memorable experience. I remember doing this with my mom 30 years ago so it was neat to relive it with my own kids. We got 2 champagne pearls and a black one and they are all stunning.”
10:00 AM - 5:30 PM
46 St George St, St. Augustine
Jewelry Stores
“Such a good experience!!! I can’t remember his name I know it started with an A but he was such a gentle and kind soul! It only took him 20ish minutes to carve my ring 10/10”
10AM - 10PM
23 Cuna St, St. Augustine
Jewelry Stores
“The energy of this place is so welcoming and positive. They have a huge selection of reasonably priced jewelry, crystals, and clothes. I highly recommend paying them a visit!”
“I found this gem while visiting in December and am now addicted to this boutique! Helena is so wonderful and helpful and just knows what will look good on you. The clothes are top quality and I have loved everything I have gotten! She always gets my orders out fast so I receive them in a couple of days. This is a must visit boutique when you’re in St Augustine or to shop on Instagram!”
“Such a cute store with lovely employees! We visit St. A several times a year and stop in every time. Cute clothing, candles (although the store is a bit overwhelming on the smell front) and stickers etc. we really enjoy our stop here every time and can typically find something for every occasion in our life.”
10:30AM - 4:30PM
1395 US-1, Street Augustine
Jewelry Stores
“I came in for a small visit, which was to put a charm on my charm bracelet. There were quite a few people in line in front of me who seem to be regulars, and this gentleman, as it appears to be a fixture in the community for quite some time as well.. the jeweler said he started out as working for Walmart in Palatka. He has a watchmaker on staff . He does custom jewelry orders , laser engraving and pretty much anything you can imagine. I decided to get a charm for my bracelet custom ordered he's going to order a state of Florida charm for me and then engrave my wedding date on it. I charged me 10 bucks to put my charm on and look at a locket on my bracelet as well to see if it needed to be repaired . He did not take upfront to order the gold charm for my bracelet, and said he would text me when he got it in; a couple of days he said. The gentleman was very kind, personable, and laid-back . He works really quick. He has plenty of jewelry for sale as well in the cases . Anything you could possibly want. But he also custom does anything you can imagine.”
10:30AM - 6PM
14 St George St, St. Augustine
Jewelry Stores
“Mr Hon was a pleasure to deal with. His store is one of the best gems of the strip. His jewelry is beautiful, and he repaired a broken silver ring to like new condition while we shopped. Very impressive jeweler. John and Eva Beene 01/28/2026”
“The cutest gift shop! I went to find gifts for others and couldn’t pass up some goodies for myself as well. All the employees are so sweet and welcoming (especially Annie!) and the prices are great!”
“This was my favorite gallery and gift shop in St. Augustine. We were visiting during the first Friday artwalk and somehow managed to miss this gallery but fortunately found it on Sunday. They have a great collection of artists including a glass artist who creates hand blown jellyfish pendant light fixtures. There is also an artist who combines very detailed mosaic and stained glass designs in an architectural window panel. There are several 2D artists as well as beautiful local jewelry. This gallery is a must visit for me every time I visit. The lady who was working on Sunday was delightful and very helpful.”
“This street is a haven for art lovers, brimming with creativity at every corner. ?✨ Galleries and artisan shops line the way, including well-known spots like Joel Bagnal Goldsmith and Jensen Pottery, both staples in the city’s art scene.
If you have an appreciation for handcrafted works and unique finds, this is the perfect place to wander and soak in the artistic energy. Take your time—there’s always something inspiring waiting to be discovered! ??️”
“A few weeks ago, I stopped into this wonderful little boutique and had such a great experience. The owner is an amazing person~ very personable, welcoming and genuinely kind. I had recently moved here in December with my dogs, and she took the time to chat with me, share local recommendations, and make me feel completely comfortable while browsing her beautiful shop.
The boutique has a lovely selection of everything from jewelry to fashion, and her assistant was very friendly as well. I never felt rushed and the atmosphere was warm and inviting.
If you get the chance, I definitely recommend stopping in and checking them out. Thank you again for such a welcoming experience<3 Love, Elizabeth”
“I am so glad I Came across this shop in St Augustine Florida. The selection of Sterling Silver Jewelry this shop has in stock is to die for. If your looking for a Piece of Sterling Silver Jewelry with a specific gemstone set in it or some Symbol made of Sterling Silver this Shop has it. She is also one of the most knowledgeable people I have ever met about Gemstones, Minerals and different Rocks found in Mother Earth. If your Looking for it. Look Here. Really Good people running this Place. I have no doubt you will be taken care of and not disappointed.”
“This was my first time inside the shop. I was able to get a small repair completed on my sterling silver chain in about five minutes. The owner was friendly and quickly finished the work. Good price and convenient hours.”
10:30AM - 6PM
127 St George St, St. Augustine
Jewelry Stores
“Fantastic find in St. Augustine! Really cool store with tons of teeth and arrowheads and coins, I got a piece of meteorite on a necklace and it's beautiful. Friendly wonderful staff!”
“This store was so unique to go to. It's located in the historic district of Saint Augustine. First time I went I got a cool book from there. Second time, a few days after to get myself a bracelet. I'm not from the area so this was my first time here to St.Augustine. If you love sea glass, you'll love this place. :)”
“First-rate Irish shop with a variety of clothing, jewelry, and hats. Lots of other things too. Dani was extremely helpful and patient when I was trying on clothing items. Highly recommended stop for your Irish gear!”
“Helpful, unpushy staff made shopping this lovely, well-stocked jewelry store an absolute delight. My friend and I had a blast shopping all the cases, in particular we'd been searching for more ocean themed pieces in sterling silver. We bought several items... left, returned and got more before leaving the city. Cannot wait to return in the future. Thank you, ladies!”
9AM - 9:30PM
56 Hypolita St, St. Augustine
Jewelry Stores
“My experience at Cottonways in St. Augustine was superb thanks to Kim!
She was gracious and very helpful and I left the store with a big smile on my face thanks to her attention to detail and her excellent customer service. Can't wait to return.
Mary”
10:30AM - 5PM
62 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine
Jewelry Stores
“This place had lots of nice things, I found a couple of thrift wishlist items. The staff were a little irritable, blamed it on the end of day hour. Some booths were very crowded and made it difficult to walk through without fear of breaking things. But overall a nice thrifting trip.”
“Blue Water Jewelers did an upgraded redesign of my wife’s wedding ring for our 35th anniversary in 2018. I’ve been back for every special occasion since then because of their friendly staff, great jewelry selection and impeccable service. Always a friendly and satisfying experience.”