Payfair Supermarket is a cool, old grocery store that offers a no-frills shopping experience without the crowds. Customers appreciate its friendly staff and the convenience of finding most essentials without long lines. The store features premium steaks, Boars Head subs sliced to order, and a good selection of local craft beers, including options from Islamorada Beer Company. Many shoppers find the prices slightly higher than larger chains, but they believe the quality and convenience make it worth it. The store is particularly convenient for quick stops, especially for beer, and offers unique items like smoked Wahoo fish dip. While it closes at 7 PM, the relaxed atmosphere and great products make it a beloved local spot.
Pay has some of the best quality beef you could buy in the market. Also, they do make sandwiches available fresh for lunch. They are incredible. Captain Bob highly recommends Pay fair supermarket.
December 2025
Mom & Pop shop like the old days. Outstanding tenderloin steak. Best I’ve ever had!!! So thrilled to find this gem.
May 2025
Cute little store with Boar's Head meats and cheeses.
