-
January 2024 by Scott Nelson
Great Sub sandwiches and everything you need from a local supermarket. Very convenient
-
January 2024 by Jeremy Aguirre
Local Keys No-Frills Grocery Store..you can get most everything needed to cook and eat without long supermarket lines or having to spend 30 minutes perusing the isles.The staff is Friendly.
-
January 2024 by Robert Harwell
If the Keys were to be swallowed by the ☆ Gulf of Mexico - Atlantic ☆, a possibility: what's next? 1. It didn't happen, and good or evil people are capitalizing. 2. It did, and humanity must move to ocean surface living -- prepared, on land... or in water. If you are asking what might happen today, I point you to yesterday... calm & bountiful. [~FDR]: There is one thing to fear fear itself.
-
September 2023 by Janice Smith
Super friendly staff!! Great local place. We stopped in to pick up beer and found a good selection from Islamorada beer company, plus some other Florida craft brews. We also picked up a smoked Wahoo fish dip that was incredible!
-
September 2023 by John Gregg
Friendly service and the best sub sandwiches in the keys..Two thumbs up ??
-
July 2023 by Salvador Borja
The best place to find anything you want.I love payfair.One of my favorite stores in the Upper Keys. Come on and find out for yourselves.
-
June 2023 by judy bradley
Not much to look at but best meat and sandwiches around!
-
March 2023 by Raul Gonzalez
Best subs in the KeysCustom cut meat fresh on the spot. My go to spot when inTavernier. The store has a great variety of items not normally found in markets. Very down to earth staff. Must go
-
November 2022 by Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor
Local supermarket, GREAT subs with fresh cut meats!
-
July 2022 by Linda Harrington
It's okay for a quick pick up of groceries open til 7pm
-
July 2022 by Maria Ward
the sad part is that this could be the coolest specialty food store if the owners wanted it to be....however for now it's the best place to get steaks n quick items......
-
March 2022 by Robin Yates
Great deli, subs and beautiful meats. The butchers and the cashier are nice and very helpful. Very deceiving from the outside, chock full on the inside
-
March 2022 by frank salafia
Love Payfair one of the only mom and Pop stores left.
-
January 2022 by michlusa
Payfair is the skilled local butcher we turn to for everything from burger meat to giant roasts. They do some aging which is a wonderful service that's hard to find. They also provide expert advice with a smile. The rest of the grocery, while small, usually has what you need to complete your meal or a basic shopping trip. Check hours before going.
-
January 2022 by Michael Schreiber
Nice little store with great meat counter
