Casey's in Dekalb, IL, located at 1001 N Annie Glidden Rd, offers excellent pizza delivery and pickup with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The menu also includes appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and essential groceries. Customers appreciate the hardworking staff, who are seen as a vital part of the community. Many reviews highlight the commitment of the employees, noting their dedication to service and food safety. However, there are some concerns about order accuracy, such as confusion between different BBQ pizzas and missing toppings. Additionally, some customers have noted that the pizza slices in the warmer are often unavailable, impacting their experience. Despite these issues, the store is generally clean, and the gas pumps provide quality fuel. Overall, Casey's is recognized for its good pizza and essential services, with hopes for improvements in pizza availability and order accuracy.
The cashier was great but whoever was cooking wasn't present!
December 2023
Usually pretty good but you should know the difference between brisket bbq pizza and chicken bbq pizza then to hang up when I call you because my pizza wasn’t supposed to have banana peppers is a bit unprofessional
October 2023
Pumps seem to go down quite often, but the store is usually clean. My biggest issue is that whenever I go in the store, there is NEVER any pizza slices. Never seems like they are cooking more pizza to stock the warmer. I just want a slice of pepperoni man. I would increase my rating if this improves
