Casey's is a popular convenience store known for its large and well-organized hot food section. Customers appreciate the friendly and thoughtful staff, especially those with special dietary needs, like gluten-free options. The store offers a variety of food items, including pizza, wraps, and other deli products. While prices can be high compared to other pizza places, many find the food satisfying and worth trying. The store's size and selection make it a recommended stop for visitors, especially in Effingham, where it is considered one of the best Casey's locations. Overall, customers enjoy the friendly atmosphere and fresh, tasty food options.
3/1/24 ordered 3 pizzas and they are absolutely the best thanks to the young man in the kitchen
December 2023
Would recommend. Safe surroundings and friendly service.
October 2023
We were in town and I needed Casey's pizza, which I haven't had for years. I got a cheese and a taco pizza. They were expensive, but they also really hit the spot. I probably wouldn't come back when I can get pizza hut for quite a bit cheaper, but it still was nice to try after so long.
