4AM - 10PM
1025 12th St, Erie
Gas Stations
“Best pizza in town. I like how the crust has a little crunch on the bottom. It's not greasy either. One pizza will feed 4 people with 2 slices each. Not bad for only $12. But they don't deliver, which is fine by me. Update: Co-Z Corner now delivers on the weekends.”
Open 24 hours
202 Washington St, Prophetstown
Gas Stations
3AM - 12AM
40 Grove St, Prophetstown
Gas Stations
“There are three things I love about Casey’s food: Taco Pizza, Breakfast Pizza, and the Box Tops program. I haven’t found a decent substitution elsewhere for any of those three things. Pro-tip: if you get the Taco Pizza, ask for the chips on the side. And use the hot sauce!Service is decent here. They had a rough night once, pizzas delayed by 45 minutes, as a result of a scheduling mishap. Management gave us the order for free, and the employees offered drinks while we waited. I appreciate not having to explicitly ask for the refund.For what it’s worth, I also feel like the environment, inside and out, is safe and comfortable.”
Open 24 hours
32000 Rte 2 and 92, Hillsdale
Gas Stations
“I don't usually leave reviews. However I have to acknowledge the absolutely incredible customer service. The cashier was literally the friendliest cashier I have ever had the pleasure of meeting. She was so delightful and we left the store feeling as though we had just left the presence of family. She was so kind and the pizza she told us about was great. Can't wait to stop in here again.”
“Today I ordered a small Supreme and some bread sticks. Thelma was working and it was some quick and on time. The pizza was one of the best I've ever had from there and we were very happy with our order. Great job Thelma”