Casey's in Galesburg, IL, located at 2364 N Seminary St, offers a variety of food and essentials with a focus on quality pizza. Customers praise their pizza delivery and pickup, highlighting made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The restaurant also serves appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and groceries, making it a convenient stop for many needs, including fuel. Many reviews mention the pizza's good taste, especially the breakfast pizza, which customers found delicious despite previous concerns about saltiness. The staff's kindness and helpfulness are also appreciated, with some noting the friendly attitude of employees in the kitchen and during pickup. However, there are some issues reported. One customer was upset about not receiving a free pizza after ordering ten through the app, feeling the process was unhelpful and the experience was frustrating. Others expressed disappointment with the service during busy times, noting long waits and poor communication about delays, which affected their overall experience. Additionally, some customers were dissatisfied with the app's limitations when customizing orders and felt billing practices could be improved. Overall, Casey's provides tasty pizza and a range of other products, backed by friendly staff, but could benefit from better communication and customer service training to enhance the overall experience.
Seen this homeless man go into the trash area and take some food out of the dumpster. Was like they knew he was coming cause was in a bag all by itself and the man ate it all down like he has never at before. Why don't employees ever hardly smile at all? Smiles make for a better day and nicer customers.
May 2026
The food is so good here I love there breakfast pizzas everyone is nice in there :)
May 2026
I think the pizza is better from this location and I'll drive all the way across town to get it. All the employees have always been friendly and knowledgeable about products in the store as well. Very clean also especially with how busy this location is being next to the interstate, hospital, and Wal-Mart Super Center.
