Casey's in West Peoria, IL, offers excellent pizza made with fresh ingredients, including scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and top-quality toppings. Customers praise the pizza as some of the best they’ve had, often highlighting the friendly and attentive staff. The store maintains a clean environment, especially the restrooms, and provides quick, friendly service that makes visits enjoyable. Besides pizza, Casey's also offers appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, household essentials, and groceries. Visitors appreciate the convenience of filling up their gas tanks with quality fuel while stopping by. Overall, Casey’s is known for its great food, helpful staff, and well-maintained facility, making it a popular spot for both pizza lovers and convenience store shoppers alike.
It's probably not the best service or food in area
April 2026
Best pizza for a gas station. Love the sausage and the sauce but that they have other fresh options as well
July 2025
I ordered a Pickel Pizza and unfortunately they were out of pickels. But I have to say. It was hands down the absolute best Casey's Pizza I've ever eaten. I felt bad for being a little pissy about the pickles. That was an amazing pizza. 👏 great job. Looking forward to ordering a lot more.
