Casey’s in Plainfield, IL, located at 14808 S Route 59, is known for its incredible pizza delivery and pickup. The pizza is made with scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, making it a favorite for many. Customers appreciate the variety of offerings, including appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and grocery essentials. The convenience of filling up gas while visiting is an added bonus. Reviews highlight the quality of the pizza, with some expressing nostalgia for its taste from previous locations. However, some customers noted that the pizza seemed smaller than they remembered. While many enjoy the food, there are mixed feelings about the user interface for online orders and the pickup process, with some finding it confusing. Customer service experiences vary; one employee received praise for being friendly and helpful, while another interaction was described as less engaging. A few reviews mentioned the pizza being very greasy, suggesting it might be more of a novelty than a regular meal option. Overall, Casey’s offers a unique mix of food and convenience, appealing to both new customers and long-time fans.
Overall, I had a wonderful experience stopping in both a gentleman were very friendly. I was shocked when I went to write this review and saw that they had like a three star review. I don’t think that’s accurate one of the few times we’re all say the review should be much higher.
August 2025
Was looking on google to see if this location is 24 hours just to stumble upon a 2.6 star or 2.8 star review which was absurd to me! Every time I come here the workers are nice and there is always pizza readily available.
May 2025
Seems like issues seen in other reviews have been solved. Visited 3x in the last week, no operational issues. Friendly staff.
