Home Insurance in Anderson, IN

“I was having trouble with my billing account, so I went into the office to receive help. Jazmin Rivera was very helpful and very kind. She fixed the issue I was having with the account. Thank you Roger Roudebush for such good service and your wonderful staff.”

“The ladies there are super nice and thorough. They walk you through everything and really help out a lot. I really enjoy conversing with them when I have to go in. Very courteous. Mr. Mike Ward a joy to talk to also”

“Support and customer service was GREAT from AshlyTaylor at the Anderson location. Good price on SR 22 and full coverage insurance. Went other places and had a higher down payment but Ashley was able to get me a low down payment AND monthly payments.10/10 I'd recommend.”

“On 8-6-2026 my wife and I, called from a RV dealership, and about 20-25 minutes later, a camper and boat and trailer were traded and a new camper was bought. And Mesha McCarty and team,had all the policies updated and the new policy started. Thank you, Mike J.”

“My homeowners and auto went way up (without any reason), so I reached out to Heather to see what she could do to help me out. She was fun and very easy to deal with and gave me options that were easy to navigate, and helped me make the best decision to both protect my home and auto and save as much money as possible. She took care of everything with my mortgage company and the switch was the easiest ever. It’s awesome to deal with folks that feel more like family! Highly recommend!!!”

“JacQues is with Farmers Insurance. She was so helpful by immediately filing a claim for a shopping center that flooded.
The claim filing system had an error so she called and had the claim file and called me back quickly. GOOD JOB”

“I am beyond grateful to Howard Webb Insurance we moved our company from another state and Kris made the entire process easy and stress free. He helped us so much with our commercial insurance coverage and he was very thorough and knowledgeable with commercial hotshot trucking. I highly recommend Howard Webb Insurance, especially Kris for insurance coverage and also they have great customer service.”

“I am very happy with my decision to switch to Shelter Insurance. My new agent Laura Sandlin was very professional and helpful with the transition. I had been with my previous insurer for 30 years so switching was not an easy decision and was a little nerve racking. Laura made it all very easy. She got me much better rates than the previous company and I had very little concern during the change. I highly recommend both Shelter Insurance and Laura Sandlin.”

“Lon Brown had always handled my insurance needs quickly and thoroughly. My rep, Susie Franklin, is always quick to answer any questions and let me know what is needed from me to get things done. I really enjoy working with a company that is so easy to get ahold of and communicate efficiently with real people. Keep up the great work!”

“Bill Maynard and his team are truly the most professional and efficient team around. I have patronized lots of businesses during my lifetime but I have to say that Bill Maynard and his team made my transition from a term life insurance policy, over to a whole life policy, very quick easy and seamless. Bill Maynard did his research and gave me the absolutely best rate possible and I'm so happy with the end result. Bill Maynard returned every single call If he was unavailable, but most times I was able to speak with him regarding my policy concerns. Super professional and knowledgeable and what he didn't know he got the answer for me. So refreshing to deal with a team that gets the job done! No procrastination or foolery just proficiency and that next level professionalism. I don't know if Bill Maynard will see this review or not but Bill if you're reading this. THANK YOU!P. Harris”

“Mr Walls has been absolutely amazing to me. I’ve had him for years as my agent and hadn’t had to bother him much until last year with my car wreck, through my divorce with changing my insurance, and now my home buying process. He was very helpful during my car accident, divorce when I had to change policies, and has been extremely helpful through my recent home buying process as well. He also took the time to guide me through my home buying process. I appreciate you very much Mr Walls!”

“I’ve been with this office for a long time and I’ve always had a good experience with them. Just wanted to take a moment to recognize Micaela in this office for her outstanding assistance with my recent claim. She kept in touch regularly throughout the process and was super helpful and friendly. I greatly appreciate her and wanted to give her a shout out! Thanks, Micaela!”

“McBeea is s of the cheapest car insurance agencies you'll fine. I was referred by a friend. I would have given 5 stars but, well my story is I was with Founder insurance who Mcbees placed me with after I had to get an sr22 for not having insurance when another cat hit me 3v3n though it wasnt my n faukt. That got set up great and was cheap. I paid the total 6 month off. Just fyi: If you get an sr22 you can't let a month go by without paying/having covèr or you license will be suspended again. I'd got into a wreck uet again wĥile with Founders. Before these 2 wrecks I'd never had one while driving 30+ years. I'm still not sure who was at fault because insurance places never said. Well Founders sent me a letter saying after my Policy was over.They would be dropping me because I was a liability I guess. SoI tried finding another Insurance policy westman b what's Mcbee. Well the first time I spoke to a woman she had found the company and told me how much it would cost down, monthly full price. I didnt need asr22 anymore Then she'd called me back ans me back and said the insurance companie she have the quote for wouldn't even cover mee because I was a liability I guess. That 2 years would have to pass without insurance. Well what even made it worse was she didn't say or check to see if any other insurance companies would quote me or insurance me. So am I suppose to drive without it? No. So I guess my only options are to try to find some company affordable that will cover me or drive, have kids one with medication condition. Yes i try to use medicaid taxis but they leave u waiting or stuck for hours and also kids school bus stops aren't in walking distance. Don't have anyone to drive us around to places so if you read this and have any suggestions are far as who I could call foe insurance please let me know. I found a few but there is no way to afford th insurance since SSI is currently our only income. My insurance at first was just $50 a month for liability to now about 300. I'm not sure what to do. I was even driving for Uber ect. Who let me drive seeing the accidents weren't Mt fault. But ai can't until I get a better car. Thanks for reading.”