Used, Vintage & Consignment near Bargersville, IN

13 locations found near Bargersville

“We went to the Open House Nov 11th and they had a nice dessert table and lots of fun booths to explore. They had a gift drawing and I won a very nice gift. Thank you to The Shoppe ?I've added a photo of my winnings. A nice $25.00 gift certificate was included too.”

4.9 Superb29 Reviews

“How have I driven down Madison Ave. and not found this small consignment boutique is totally beyond me. My girlfriend told me about this cute shop last week during lunch. Thank you, Mardena.Abby's shop is full of women's clothing, jewelry, and accessories. The shop is well-organized, extremely clean, and feels warm and inviting. I even found several items with tags still on, plus it's easy to find sizes and prices. Abby offers sizes XS - 3X, and the clothing was in good to excellent condition and very affordable. She has a $4 rack, a 50% off rack, and then a new arrival rack. I loved the variety of styles with the'70s vibe to cute summer dresses, capri's, fun tops, and bib-overalls. I was also pleased to find a dressing room to try on the consignment items I found before buying.If you're spring cleaning your closets, bring in your gently used clothing and make some cash.Every Monday at 6:35 p.m. check out their Facebook live event to shop online! They go fast, so be ready to message Abby to purchase. This small business is owned by a woman who loves clothing and following her dream. Abby is super nice and down to earth. We chatted for a few minutes, and she knew my friend immediately, plus many of her family who shop here. Abby is definitely a people person and makes you feel welcomed. Come and support her consignment business and check out the live Facebook event on Mondays.”

4.9 Superb25 Reviews

“I went to Franklin as part of their annual holiday shopping weekend. Love shopping at the shops on Jefferson Street and this shop was no exception. Walking in to the shop you immediately got the holiday vibe. Most of the shop was dedicated to Christmas and it was do much fun checking out all of the holiday ornaments and the decor. I really loved the tall Christmas trees made out of old doors, people are ingenious. There were snow globes and mittens and so many fun things here.”

4.6 Superb57 Reviews

“Being an out of state customer I was a little apprehensive but the communication from Melissa was amazing! Shipping was very affordable and quick. Items were as described and at a great price. I just love the bags, thank you!!”

4.2 Good119 Reviews

“Visited for the first time. Nice store and prices seem fair for a small buisness. Lady was nice when I purchased my items. Didn't have a lot in my daughters size, but it seems to be a popular size right now anyway. I will definitely be back!”

4 Good56 Reviews

“Very helpful and every time we donate there's always someone there to help. They never turn us down. Thank you for letting us donate great stuff. See you in the future”

3.9 Good96 Reviews

“Manager Autumn was very helpful as i’ve never been to an outlet before! she was super kind and good at explaining all the “rules and regulations”. I will be back again to visit. Thanks Autumn!”

3.7 Good129 Reviews

“07/15/2025 We called to ask if they had size 13 rollerblades in stock and the gentleman on the phone said yes, so next day we drove to the store. While trying on that pair, they said they had another pair just come so we tried those on and bought those instead. Trevor and the other gentleman were great to work with, very helpful and knowledgeable with the stick in the store.

Definitely would recommend this store for your used sports equipment.”

3.5 Good81 Reviews

“I bought a couple new outfits.
There's A LOT of different sizes, styles and clothing brands for Men and women of all ages sold here.(reasonably priced)
They have A LOT of kids and toddler clothing as well.(reasonably priced)
They have A LOT of glassware, pots, pans, cooking utensils and plastic dishes as well.( reasonably priced)
They have A LOT of home decor items, books and DVDs of every genre.(reasonably priced)
They also have a wide variety of shoes for men, women and teens. I do think some of the shoes are very over priced but not all of them.
Literally they probably have ANYTHING you need!!”

3.5 Good68 Reviews

“One of my favorite goodwill’s in the area, generally fair pricing. However a few weeks ago when we visited who I believe is the manager was on a smoke break when we pulled up (I believe they were the proper feet from the entrance but still very in front of customers) and when we left 45 mins later they were in another smoke break already! Ridiculous!”

3.5 Good65 Reviews

“The clothing is all mixed up on sizes. The XL-3xl has a lot of small and mediums mixed in. So if you don't mind sorting through the sizes, some great finds.The items are priced well here. The cashier was really nice.”

3.4 Good112 Reviews

“These 2 cashier girls, both with red hair, were very sweet and kind, after I forgot my receipt, I went back home to get it, and as soon as I came back, they instantly remembered me, one of their names is Lizzy, I hope they stay for a while”

3.3 Good82 Reviews

“Very clean and organized. The selection is great and everything is displayed beautifully. What a gem! I wish they could have bought more from me however I will definitely return.”

2.8 Average175 Reviews