Used, Vintage & Consignment in Indianapolis, IN

30 locations found near Indianapolis

“Pen and Pink is one of the coolest finds from the Indy’s Indie Book Crawl. A small store packed with an impressive amount of unique finds. The lady running the store was kind, energetic, and super helpful. I bought my first blind date with a book and can’t wait to read it!”

5 Superb85 Reviews

“Midland Arts & Antiques is a HUGE antique mall — definitely plan to spend some time browsing because there is so much to see. The building itself has a really cool industrial vibe, and the variety of booths and vintage pieces was impressive. We kept finding interesting items around every corner.
Parking was easy, and the entrance is clearly marked once you know where to go. The layout inside is spacious with wide walkways in most areas.
Accessibility note: I personally did not see obvious wheelchair or elevator accommodations during our visit. However, staff were moving large carts between levels, and there is a service-style lift at the storefront that appears to be used for moving items. If accessibility is important for your visit, it may be worth calling ahead to confirm current options.
Overall, this is a fun place to explore if you enjoy antiques, vintage décor, and unique finds. Definitely worth stopping in if you're in the Indianapolis area.”

4.5 Superb266 Reviews

“This second-hand toy store is a total nostalgia hit! I was over the moon to find the exact toy I loved as a kid here—and to my surprise, it still works perfectly, just like I remembered. I can’t thank the store enough for bringing back such sweet childhood memories. If you’re after a blast from the past, this place is a must-visit!”

4.7 Superb112 Reviews

“This store is SO CUTE. Such an surprising mix of treasures. The things that surprised me most were the hats/facinators and also the ethnic apparel- especally Indian (i am not very well familiar so forgive me). So sooo fun to spend hours just looking at each hanger one by one.”

4.6 Superb136 Reviews

“Vintage 54 is a fun antique store to spend some time in. A large variety of antiques at reasonable prices. The staff is always very friendly and always willing to help and/or answer questions.”

4.9 Superb69 Reviews

“This is the second one we have visited in the area. We will be going back to this one. Clean nice service, a little confused on where to find what I want, but over all great experience”

4.2 Good224 Reviews

“Suchhhhh a gem!!! I absolutely love this store. Every time I’m in the area I have to stop in and I never fail to find something incredible. So thoughtfully curated. Obsessed!”

4.8 Superb22 Reviews

“Very cool little shop with lots of treasures and curiosities. Found two cool, vintage manequins at a great price, a great classic Chinese soda advertisement poster and creepy old doll perfect for Halloween.
Marshall is super nice and easy going. I stop by every few weeks to chat and browse. I always find something to pique my interest!”

4.5 Superb77 Reviews

“We love this store! Unique furnishings, nice people, great deals. We come here often because their merchandise is always changing. Great place to shop - highly recommend!”

4.2 Good112 Reviews

“Cute place for fun decor and flea finds!

They currently have Wizard of Oz/Wicked ornaments and I also love the unique stones, jewelry and gems.”

4.9 Superb11 Reviews

“Amazing store in the Indy area for unique design and art! We’ve found so many cherished pieces here and the prices are always competitive.

The owner is one of the kindest and most caring people I know and if you experience something else I think that may be a you problem….”

4.5 Superb25 Reviews

“Amazing vintage clothes! Love this store - it always has unique clothes that are styled so cute. Every time I go, they have new clothes and always on trend. My fav place by far!”

4.2 Good30 Reviews

“Really amazing selection of both men’s and women’s vintage! Staff were super helpful in helping me find items, and with how to take care of my items. Best vintage in Indy!”

4 Good81 Reviews

“This goodwill was so clean and organized, I wasn't scared to pick up certain items. I know this is a ritzyer part of town compared to where I live and the Goodwill's that are in my area, but they didn't have opened used hygiene products (which they are not supposed to sell) none of their kitchen appliances had mold or food or mystery stuff in them they were all clean. And I found some great items. I find good stuff around my typical ones too but they have items that are in my opinion a serious health concern to even have in the store and they tend to be so packed full of bs items that you know no one is going to buy and that should have never been put out for sale let alone not put straight into the trash.”

4.1 Good70 Reviews

“I was just wondering, enjoying a wonderful day and decided to stop at one of my favorite bargain stores. I found a couple of great deals. Staff were busy and friendly. And, I look forward to returning soon. ??”

3.9 Good91 Reviews

“I stopped by Goodwill Store one afternoon just to browse, not really expecting much. After digging through a few racks, I actually found a couple cool items for cheap. That’s kind of the fun of it—you never know what you’ll come across. It’s simple, a little messy, but perfect if you enjoy the thrill of thrift hunting.”

3.8 Good93 Reviews

“Found this shop passing through Indiana on a road trip, and it did not disappoint. They had a huge variety of vintage clothing that was neatly organized, super reasonable prices, great taste in music, and the shop owner was so kind. 10/10 recommend!!”

3.8 Good24 Reviews

“Decent selection, but no fitting rooms. Returns are store credit, but you can use it at any network Goodwill in the area. This store is clean and relatively organized (for a thrift store).”

3.7 Good123 Reviews

“The Google information seems to be wrong. We found them open but in a different location around the corner. 911 E Michigan St. Not used to going to there new location and looking for them. But found what we were looking for!”

3.7 Good20 Reviews

“I found a most incredible item and at first, I didn't know how I would use it! I'm going to hang necklaces and bracelets on it. This item is a work of art! Amazing at $9.99!!”

3.6 Good98 Reviews

“I had questions and it seemed like only 1 person had all the answers and was busy. I ended up leaving without purchasing anything. Overall it was still a nice store and probably one of the cleanest locations. I will go back at another time.”

3.6 Good114 Reviews

“Great selection of clothing and the staff was extremely accommodating and nice towards me and my family. Will be coming here over and over again. Thank you for the help today!”

3.5 Good95 Reviews

“My friend today in need if a dryer! Doing a little searching here or there on marketplace with little to no success on a dryer mainly over priced as to the reason! She decided maybe check in at goodwill and see if they have one! Blessings come I'm ways you can't imagine or when, reluctantly maybe to many dryers or no space! She managed to buy one at a low price you wouldn't believe! I am so grateful that Goodwill stores exist and how far they go to help someone in need! ??”

3.5 Good102 Reviews

“I really haven't stopped into a goodwill since they took the tag cookie sales away, but decided to see what they had. I walked around for a min and even though I was shocked by the prices, I wasn't. I've read many reviews and watched YouTube videos on how Goodwill prices have escalated, and they truly have. This store wasn't busy and I ran into the usual overcrowding shelves, but with the prices they have on the merchandise........I can see why they was full and overcrowded! I was looking for a basic muffin pan and found one and surprisingly for it being almost brand new, it was only $2.99! And that is my kind of price! I don't know to be mad at goodwill for their prices, but they could at least bring back the sale tag for the week to give a customer a reason to go in their doors.”

3.5 Good131 Reviews

“I didn't really believe they bought close with my niece told me but she doesn't lie and we went and I'll be darn they bought my clothes fifty bucks really isn't much but for me now having heart surgery and not having a job and no workers unemployment that money got me through the week very professional but laid-back at the same time making you feel more I thought they were awesome and would definitely recommend”

3.5 Good150 Reviews

“I use this store frequently. My kids are in sports and need equipment every season. This place makes it easy to essentially exchange one set of equip for another.”

3.3 Good87 Reviews

“It was a fun experience searching through the bins for treasures. $1.99 per pound for items. There are so many bins to dig through and they rotate the old bins with new ones every so often.”

3.4 Good118 Reviews

“These 2 cashier girls, both with red hair, were very sweet and kind, after I forgot my receipt, I went back home to get it, and as soon as I came back, they instantly remembered me, one of their names is Lizzy, I hope they stay for a while”

3.3 Good92 Reviews

“Brandy is an amazing manager at this location! I shop here frequently and ever since she’s been here I can see changes being made. I actually shop here more often nowThank you Brandy!”

3.3 Good103 Reviews