Pierce Jewelers is a family-owned jewelry store located in Carmel, IN, serving the Indianapolis area. They offer a wide selection of mined and lab-grown diamond engagement and wedding rings, along with various colorful gemstones. The store specializes in custom designs, with jewelry made right on site, ensuring personalized and unique pieces. Customers can also take advantage of services such as jewelry repair, estate buying and selling, gold buying, watch batteries, and appraisals. Private appointments are available for a more personalized experience. Many reviews highlight the friendly and welcoming atmosphere of Pierce Jewelers. Customers appreciate the attentive service, where staff take the time to listen, answer questions, and educate about jewelry and diamonds. The team is praised for helping clients find the perfect pieces, whether upgrading wedding rings or creating custom engagement rings. The quality of work, especially in repairs, is highly regarded, with jewelry often looking like new afterward. Prices are considered reasonable, with flexible payment options that make purchasing easier. Overall, Pierce Jewelers is known for its exceptional customer care, expertise, and commitment to making each experience special.
The knowledge of everyone in this store is absolutely amazing. John helped me to redesign a ring I had and created my engagement ring to absolute perfection. Their pieces are beautiful and unique. I can’t say enough.
January 2026
Friendly, knowledgable and professional. Chuck was very approachable/helpful with fixing my watch. I will absolutely utilize Pierce in the near future. Thanks again.
November 2025
Pierce Jewelers is definitely the place to go for any of your jewelry needs! This place outperforms the larger stores by miles and at more reasonable prices. I’ve been using them for years for all sorts of things and they always come through. I suggest you give them a try and you’ll see what I mean.
