Casey's at 409 E Lincoln Ave offers fuel, groceries, and household essentials. It is known for its pizza featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The location also has appetizers, sweet treats, and drinks. Reviews highlight an amazing, soft, and chewy PB&J stuffed cookie, calling it the best. Service experiences vary, with some employees noted as friendly and providing great, quick service to rectify issues. However, other feedback mentions that prepared food like sandwiches is not always fresh or available, and some employees seem unhappy. The pizza and special cookies receive strong praise from many customers.
Amazing! The guy working the food area (pizza) on Saturday April 27th around 6pm was amazing! So friendly, and great service! He quickly helped rectify a crust issue with my order. This will now be my go-to Casey’s in the area
December 2023
Decent gas station with OK food. Nice clean staff. Mostly.
May 2023
Charli and Kaleb are very friendly have a very clean store and had a great attitude the whole way through
