Casey's in Evansville is a clean and modern gas station with a convenient store. It offers quality fuels and a wide, easy-to-maneuver parking lot. The store is well-stocked with household essentials, groceries, appetizers, sweet treats, and drinks. It is especially known for its awesome and very good pizza, which features made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings for delivery or pickup. The staff is consistently described as great, very helpful, friendly, and nice, often providing excellent service even when busy. Customers report good deals available through the app and rewards.
great little convent store has the best Mac and cheese 🧀 ohh the pizza 🍕 😋
December 2025
I eat at Casey’s all across the country as I drive a truck. Stopped in this location and got a pizza. The fella cooking did amazing! He cooked the pizza perfectly how I wanted it. Definitely make sure to stop here when I’m in the area again!!
August 2024
Very helpful and friendly staff, very good deals (when used in conjunction with their app/ rewards), and awesome food... Especially when it comes to their pizza ? Any time I can go to a Casey's, I won't go to any other gas station/ convince store.
