-
February 2024 by Charles “Mikey”
They are always out of pizza every time I go there. If that wasn't the case it would be getting a better review because everything else is fine. But when they are out of pizza every time you go there, and the pizza is sooo good, it leaves a patron a little upset.
-
December 2023 by Sarah Hartman
Decent enough gas station, pumps are old fashioned but the prices were very reasonable. Parking lot plenty big to maneuver pumps.
-
December 2023 by koolaid
found a cockroach giving birth inside of my coffee and when i contacted management about the situation, Madison told me that's just indiana style. i'm from California btw. but to feel better i went to buy a fresh pizza just to see mice crawling around the kitchen squeaking to the beat of the song that was playing. so not only do they have mice, they have mice on crack.
-
June 2023 by Kenny Miles
best Casey's general store in the state good food great employee's. the one thing that sets them apart from the rest is they have prep guy who always is working hard. he makes the best cookies and salads hands down. when in town check out the Casey's on oak hill you won't regret it.
-
June 2023 by Alexis Brunette
By far the best Casey's in town. You can tell they have a staff that legitimately CARES about their store and team. If there's ever an issue with food, they are accomadating, friendly and quick to fix it. Working withthe public can be hard...but friendly smiles and a positive environment/attitudes is what keeps people coming back for more! Thank you for holding your standards to the Casey's standard:)
-
June 2023 by kennyv milesbh
best and cleanest in town don't know what that Brandon guy was talking about sounds to me that may been withdrawing from whatever he was on. just saying
-
May 2023 by Brandon Hatcher
I worked here and after what o have seen. I'll never buy food here again. Sad part is I love the pizza but it's a very nasty kitchen. The vent for oven leaks water ever time it rains and allways felt sick at the end of my shift(black mold)!
-
May 2023 by james burns
Would not answer phone...was on line waiting for 4 minutes..
-
August 2022 by Jon Doe
I've worked at the Santa Claus Casey's for over a year, and I've gotta say: this is the WORST Casey's I have ever eaten at. The pizza I got was super greasy and soggy, I could barely eat it. They use the same equipment they've been using since the store opened for business, and the store itself looks ANCIENT. It tells you a lot about the management and the corporate management who work for that store, how they feel about working there. I absolutely do not recommend eating any food made there.
-
August 2022 by Prof. Chaos
Love the pizza but being told that it will be ready by a certain time and you go to pick it up and its just being made. Sounds like you need to hire faster people for the kitchen.
-
August 2022 by Chris B.
Worse pizza I've ever had. What toppings? I guess their definition of "ultimate toppings" is: missing toppings. Add to the lack of toppings, pizza was less than half baked. I called the location, the guy that answered couldn't have been less interested or distracted. No customer service at this place. Pizza cost $20.99 NOT including tax and tip. Not worth anything. Honestly, the worst Little Caesars pizza is better than Casey's. Horrible pizza, horrible customer service. Save yourselves some aggravation and a lightened wallet and take your business elsewhere. I won't make this mistake again. Negative stars ought to be an option.
-
July 2022 by Cathy Hufford
Great store,pple are so friend,and it has clean bathrooms
-
February 2022 by Jason Butler
Fantastic pizza from a gas station! Checkout the app for pizza deals that will save you money.Chicken bacon ranch pizza is very good as well.
-
February 2022 by Christopher Doehrmann
Love the pizza but being told that it will be ready by a certain time and you go to pick it up and its just being made. Sounds like you need to hire faster people for the kitchen.
-
January 2022 by Darby Omega
I've worked at the Santa Claus Casey's for over a year, and I've gotta say: this is the WORST Casey's I have ever eaten at. The pizza I got was super greasy and soggy, I could barely eat it. They use the same equipment they've been using since the store opened for business, and the store itself looks ANCIENT. It tells you a lot about the management and the corporate management who work for that store, how they feel about working there. I absolutely do not recommend eating any food made there.
