Casey's at 1900 Oak Hill Rd in Evansville, IN offers an impressive array of services, from delicious made-from-scratch pizza with fresh toppings to a variety of appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and household essentials. Customers praise the excellent customer service, with the store manager and kitchen staff going above and beyond to ensure orders are ready on time and any issues are promptly addressed. While the pizza is widely acclaimed as the best in the area, some customers have expressed frustration when the store runs out of it, a common occurrence. However, the overall experience at this Casey's is overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers highlighting the friendly staff, clean facilities, and reasonable fuel prices. One reviewer even went so far as to call it the "best Casey's general store in the state," praising the hardworking prep staff who make the best cookies and salads. Whether you're stopping in for a quick bite, picking up groceries, or fueling up your vehicle, Casey's at 1900 Oak Hill Rd is a reliable and customer-focused destination that strives to meet the needs of the local community.
A great place to fuel up and to grab drinks and snacks! Casey's Rewards helps you save money and provides deals and offers for you, as well!
August 2026
I LOVE CASEYS PIZZA AND FOOD!!! However, I don't usually like to get gas there. I do not feel it is the best gas. Download the app for great deals and rewards!!!
January 2026
Love the workers there very nice people your business is welcomed there.
