“This was a really interesting shopping experience. I'd consider coming here to furnish my home. There were many interesting finds. The place is also massive. It would take an hour to see everything. There are booths that'd be great for costuming, old dinner ware, furniture, posters, really a little of everything.I will note that there aren't any $50 dressers, so if you're looking for a steal, that won't happen. Prices are fair, but I wouldn't say that these are flea market prices.”
“Anytime I’m down in NuLu I ALWAYS make a point to stop by Sugar Town! They even set up booths at the local outdoor markets every once and awhile. It always makes the day a little more sweet! Go get yo self a new fit, YOU DESERVE IT!”
“Absolutely adore this place & everything about it. Some really interesting antique/vintage finds, cheap beer, and the coolest cat in life. Was able to bring some food from around the corner, have a drink and shop. Can't think of a better way to spend an afternoon. Can't wait to return to see Mr. Louis & check out fun finds.”
“All of the workers are so nice and helpful if I have ever needed it. I love the selection of clothes they have and the records. They also have some cool nicknacks and scrapbooking stuff, if you are into that. There clothes are not super expensive, and I have found some really nice classic pieces for my closet here!”
“This is one of my favorite thrift stores in the area. They are reasonably priced, volunteer ran and friendly. I prefer to take my donations here since the money goes to a good cause- helping furry friends! I always find a little something to take home with me.”
“I brought my daughter here for her prom dress shopping. She found the dress of her dreams and was treated way better than she was at another formal store. I am very excited for my daughter and I can't wait to bring her back for more shopping!”
“This place has awesome vintage apparel and super fair prices :) Their selection is some of the best that I’ve found from my times in Louisville and Southern Indiana.Ryan and his mom are so kind, helpful, and awesome to be around! Definitely give this store a visit if you’re in the area”
“Visiting from Nashville and loved this store! Everything is super cool and really reasonably priced!! The owner is also so sweet! Definitely will come back next time we’re in town”
“Great experience— the selection was so good. Highly curated, but still something for everyone. Will definitely be making another trip from Indy to go again.”
“All the people complaining about the "don't steal/move stuff around" signs makes me wonder if they've ever worked retail/customer service. The theft signs are almost all by the little jewelry pieces and the moving sign is in a basement full of breakable, organized items. It's not unreasonable, nor is it even unusual for thrift shops.
On a nicer note: There are a ton of neat items! Cool boxes and furniture pieces and candlestick holders were some of my favorites. It's admittedly not as trendy as some thrift shops, however it's way more reasonably priced and not lacking in neat finds. The man at the counter was very nice and let me give his dog a treat. I would recommend for people who like decor and kitchenware and furniture.”
“Heard great things from friends and family. Decided to visit and shop. Found quiet a few nice collared men's shirts for my father in law. My mother in law found some nice things as well. The store was clean and nicely organized. Prices were affordable. Wish our Tennessee version thrift on a mission was as nice and affordable.”
“Great shop with a truly eclectic collection of toys, games, music, books, clothes from 60s-80s. Condition is definitely above average and the owner is a very helpful and friendly person. My wife and I had so much fun yelling at each other "Come check this out!" So much to see in a small shop. The owner does an outstanding job of making effective use of space. Everything stands out! Hard to focus on any one thing for long and I mean that as a compliment! Thanks to the owner for such a fun experience!”
“Awesome clothes and really good customer service I will definitely be coming back in the future I definitely recommend! I sold clothes and they went through them and exchanged them for cash.”
“This place is rad! They’ve got a huge selection and you can tell the owner is thoughtful about what’s going on the racks. It’s hard to walk out empty handed!”
“it’s a typical Goodwill, which is always hit and miss and a mixed bag of pros and con. Their prices are steep on certain items which is wild for a secondhand store selling donations.”
“Shout out to Nick at the drop off part of goodwill. I got out to give my donation and found out one of my tires were flat. I pulled over to the side and he helped me change my tire all while going back and forth helping other customers at the donation drive through. He did not have to do that at all. He offered to help me amd was very kind. I am especially grateful because my little ones were with me. Thank you, Nick! Nick needs a promotion!”
“I always have a great experience here! The couple that run this store are amazing!! They are always so nice and talk to the kids. I never have to worry about what I’m buying here because they always do such a thorough look over of the items, and only consign the best. Great deals! I will continue to use this store for a very long time!!”
“Clean, great selection, kinda pricey for second hand material objects. Goodwill has gotten too expensive. 4 bucks for a shirt and 10 for jeans?? Some people don't make that an hour so I no longer visit them but once a year. I should have spent 35 but I spent 80. For a handful of things. SMH.”