Sam's Club Gas Station in Indianapolis has recently shifted to a Members-only fuel station, no longer selling fuel to non-Members. This change means that the fuel prices now always reflect the Member discount, which many customers find to be some of the best prices in town. While gas is well priced, the layout can be confusing and attendants are sometimes too busy chatting to help. A great feature for the pump is Scan and Go, allowing customers to easily scan their phone to get gas and shop.
Aside from fuel, Sam's Club is known for its wide range of products, including bakery items, water, trash bags, and paper towels, which many find to be affordable and good quality. The store also offers premade meals, such as the Marry Me Chicken & Tortellini, which is described as convenient and tasting really good. Some reviews compare it to other big stores, noting that while it can be similar to Walmart in organization and product quality, the prices on some items are comparable or slightly higher than competitors like Costco, especially on non-produce items.
Shopping here can be quick, thanks to many self-checkout lanes, but the checkout process might be slow at times due to limited staff. Overall, customers recommend a membership for the savings and quality, and they enjoy shopping for both fuel and everyday essentials at Sam's Club Gas Station.
Shelves are fully stocked and nice organized manner
August 2025
I think that the area for waiting for the pumps after entrance onto the station site is too small.
July 2025
Love getting much more affordable gasoline! The latest price for regular unleaded is $2.69 a gallon! Got love that whereas everyone else seems to be hovering around 3.29! Premium fuel is also offered at about a $1 more per gallon.