The Toy Pit is Indy's largest, highest-rated, and longest-established spot for action figures and collectibles. Spanning over 5,000 square feet, the store boasts a vast and diverse inventory of vintage and modern items, including action figures, records, t-shirts, and video games. The Toy Pit is the only store in the Indianapolis area that guarantees cash on the spot for any size collection, making it a popular destination for collectors looking to buy, sell, or trade. With a small but knowledgeable and friendly staff of 3 employees, the store offers excellent customer service and a welcoming atmosphere. Customers praise the store's great value, diverse selection, and discount sale events, describing it as a nostalgic trip back to their childhood. The Toy Pit is a must-visit destination for fans of Marvel, Star Wars, GI Joe, Transformers, Funko Pops, and more, with a bonus of a brewery next door.
Love this place. They always take good care of you and are very knowledgeable. They have everything… anime, pops, tnmt, transformers, marvel, dc, mafex, storm collectibles, wrestling, Star Wars and a ton more. Lots of obscure stuff. You’ll walk out with a lot more than you originally came in for.
June 2026
Definitely a toy store that you need to experience. Highly recommend. Staff was so nice and knowledgeable. We drove from Chicago down here to visit. Man it didn't disappoint! One of the best toy stores we have been to.
June 2026
So cool! So many awesome toys and collectables! Pretty pricey, but if you're looking for something specific, they just might have it.
