Toy Stores in Indianapolis, IN

24 locations found near Indianapolis
View Map

“Fantastic store that has literally everything including knowledgeable and friendly employees/owners. Everything was clean, well placed, well lit, and easy to find. Prices were fair, selection was massive, and they have some amazing terrain and nerdy decor. Great play areas with the perfect tables.This is by far my favorite store in Indy.”

4.9 Superb55 Reviews

“Been going here ever since I was 13 and about to be 20 this year. Love this place, my go to for all my collecting needs, From Dragon Ball to Power Rangers, Marvel etc. they got it all. I could never ask for a better place for figures and collectibles highly recommend”

4.8 Superb65 Reviews

“I love this place. We haven't been residents of Indiana for almost 4 years. We drove past and saw it was open on Friday night and popped in to look around. The Store's selection is fantastic and the pricing is about where I expected it to be for a brick and Mortar.”

4.7 Superb49 Reviews

“This store is wonderful, the employees are so nice and kind. The lady at the front desk gave me and my family a backstage tour on the parts section and she also turned on the droid factory for us. We got some custom parts and B2 battle droids and both are great! Highly recommend great place!”

4.7 Superb46 Reviews

“I checked this place out today for the first time. they had so many cool toys and collectibles throughout the decades. they had action figures, collector cards, funko pops and more. The items were priced fairly it seemed based on the majority of what i saw. the guy at the counter was very knowledgeable about a lot of the toys and was very friendly. they had a selection of drinks and freeze dried candy at the front to choose from as well.”

4.8 Superb29 Reviews

“Wonderful selection and super friendly employees. Very talkative and fun even with just buying a couple mystery packs. Everything was very clean and well kept. Always love stopping at a Lego store!”

4.8 Superb28 Reviews

“Bought some cool dice from here for my DND campaign and some Pokémon cards. All at great prices. The store is fun to walk around. The staff is very nice and kind. They chatted with us and made sure we got any help we needed finding items. Would highly recommend this store for your comic book and nerdy needs!”

4.7 Superb38 Reviews

“Worth the drive to check it out! An absolute gem of a shop; had exactly what I wanted and more! Great selection of games, minis, Bandai models(They had several Perfect Grades on the shelf; never saw this in any other hobby store!), and so much more! Definitely worth stopping in, because you’ll definitely leave satisfied!”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

“I absolutely Love this place come here about once a week. They always have really good deals going on very cheap very affordable if you’re a new parent, I would highly suggest going here.”

4.5 Superb64 Reviews

“They got mostly everything vintage! A huge collection of Funko pops to old vintage TV shows merchandise like Power Ranges, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Star Wars, and much more! They are having a big sale, so please come and check it out!”

4.5 Superb42 Reviews

“What a sweet bookstore that I have probably passed a zillion times over the years. This cost little bookstore neighbors Kincaids Meat Market, Illinois Street Food Emporium and several other sweet local businesses. I was amazed to find out that they've been around for quite some time (and embarrassed that I was oblivious). The store offers a variety of children's books, educational toys and small entertaining items like sticker books, etc (what I like to call "restaurant activities). They also had a few little play stations like a train set to make the visit itself entertaining for kiddos. The staff was both friendly and warm - just what you love to see with a neighborhood bookstore. Looking forward to future visits.”

4.7 Superb13 Reviews

“What a wonderful store! The store had wonderful options for all budgets and the store associate was incredibly helpful, helping me find a perfect gift. Thank you!”

5 Superb5 Reviews

“Very happy with the service! I ordered some animal figurines for my daughter's birthday & everything arrived quickly. One item was wrong & another broke, probably during shipping. I called & left a message & sent an email & I'm not kidding when I say maybe an hour later I received an email saying my order was shipped along with a message saying I don't have to return the wrong item. I didn't think I'd receive it before my daughter's birthday since it was in 3 days & it literally arrived on her birthday! Awesome service & fast!”

4.6 Superb9 Reviews

“Really cute stuff and it's great that is located inside of Walmart having said that oh my mom got her ears pierced. Well actually Repair she's 80 years old and the woman didn't pay enough attention too much that she did culminating in my mom having the whole way off base with the other ear. She wasn't even able to keep it in so I realize that this could be a particular employee. The others might be great store is clean and it is as large with as much inventory as any other shop of the same:) Just be sure the person who pierces your ears has experience doing it”

4.4 Superb25 Reviews

“One of my favorite places. It is the main place I usually come to when shopping for art supplies. It is a store I look forward to revisiting. I appreciate how they stock inventory uncommon in other stores. Although I am not a teacher, I appreciate their education supplies. The people there are usually reserved but helpful. I like how they are non-salesy. I consider United Art and Education as a toy store that has allowed me to explore new and familiar tools to bring my imagination to life ?.I feel lucky to consider this establishment as my local art supply store.”

4.3 Superb45 Reviews

“Thank you for always being so supportive of The Benton House.We can’t count the number of times and ways you’ve supported us.We love you and all you do, often silently, to support the neighborhood!”

4.3 Superb39 Reviews

“I found the owner of Figure Collections to be extremely helpful. He answered all the questions I had about what was in stock for particular figures, even went so far as to send a couple of photos of what was available. Package was shipped and received in excellent condition and in a timely manner. The figures ordered are in great shape and exactly what I was looking for, at an amazing price!”

4.4 Superb8 Reviews

“Great place to get supplies for modeling. However I haven't had a reason to go since they don't seem to carry nearly as many gundam models since the pandemic. Hopefully they have an easier time acquiring these since they were the only decent option in the state for gunpla.”

4.2 Good38 Reviews

“What's nice is you can get single dollar amounts for your Xbox (no other consoles) for gift cards. They will be printed pass codes. I do wish they could do this with all consoles because of taxes are still applied online. Good atmosphere and employees.”

4.2 Good71 Reviews

“There are a number of fun toys, action figures, games, and curiosities to be had here. There seems to be a sale or clearance on at any given time. A LOT of your favorite pop culture fandoms are represented here. Go! (and find your favorite geeky treasure!)”

3.8 Good6 Reviews

“Had quite a bit of things I didn't have enough time to finish my shopping but when I go back I'll do much more of a browsing and check-out prices more.”

4.1 Good60 Reviews

“You can find good deals here. I just bought thick long bath towels on sale for only $7 a piece. In the past, I've purchased golf umbrellas and even Dove dark chocolate. It's hit or miss with different products on each visit, but it's definitely worth a look.”

4.1 Good164 Reviews

“I had a rough experience at this location, but what I respect is the manager reaching out to me, taking responsibility and apologizing for my experience. I have faith that store leadership is working to provide a great experience for all customers.”

3.4 Good44 Reviews

“Amber and Anna we're absolutely amazing with the customer service they provided. I highly recommend people coming to this Build-A-Bear by far the best experience my family has had at any location.”

3 Average34 Reviews

You May Also Like