“Good to go to. A bit busy on Fridays after 5ish but they have a large selection of tabletop games and some card games. 5 bucks a head for table rental without a time limit except for closing. Canned cold soft drinks and little Debbie type snacks able to be bought at cheaper than I was expecting prices.”
“Phenomenal experience, here. Tons of short boxes to browse through...and some really good prices on most. Snagged a few wall books, too. Went back 3 times, during my stay in Indy.”
“This place was awesome. I have seen it many times but never stopped. We mainly came I'm because my son loves pokemon cards. Lots of those but so many toys from my childhood. Very cool place.”
10AM - 8PM
6020 E 82nd St Space 870, Indianapolis
Toy Stores
“Very good experience! The staff were amazing. Without promoting a staff member mentioned that a train wasn't going to work with the track set my son had picked. Absolutely saved a ton of disappointment on my son's birthday trip to the store.”
“Game Preserve is always one of our go-to place for board games. They have an excellent selection, and it’s rare that we’re looking for something they don’t have. While we usually don’t play games there, it’s great that they even have a dedicated game room for anyone who wants that experience.
Today we stopped in to pick up Lost Ruins of Arnak, and of course they had it — along with the expansions. Knowledgeable staff, great inventory, and a true passion for board games. If you enjoy tabletop gaming at any level, this place is a must-visit.”
“This store offers some of the most thoughtfully designed and detailed toys you can find. Everything feels intentional rather than mass-produced or disposable. These toys are clearly chosen with a purpose in mind not just filler items. Most of the toys have floor examples as well so you can see how they work! They also have so many fun crafts and projects for all ages. It’s really the best!”
“Wonderful kids bookstore. The shelves are pretty full but super organized. The staff is friendly and helpful. Plenty of free parking on the street and behind the building.”
“Best buy/sell lego store out there! I love coming here to look around and buy lego from their huge selection of stuff. Everyone is nice and helpful. This place is awesome I cannot wait to come back!”
“Ordered a couple of Breyer models and they shipped the same day! They arrived the next day as well, it probably helps that I am a state away but I was very impressed with the service and will definitely order my models more regularly from this store!”
“Super Fast Shipping! Really Safe Packaging! Everything was on sale on the website. And Adam Bomb arrived on like the 3rd day! Couldn't be more pleased. The Jakks BCA line was my childhood, and they are still my favorite wrestling figures. This is a most for any collector. 5 Stars”
10AM - 8PM
1300 E 86th St Suite 30, Indianapolis
Toy Stores
“I absolutely love this store! I always find whatever I need for my preschool. The only issue that I have is that it’s so far from where I live/work. If the store was closer I would definitely shop there more often.”
“I've been to many Ollie's hell i built 2 of them and this one here has the biggest selection by far. They might need to lay off the following around thing tho. Studio typing is not cool”
“Thank you for always being so supportive of The Benton House.We can’t count the number of times and ways you’ve supported us.We love you and all you do, often silently, to support the neighborhood!”
“They got mostly everything vintage! A huge collection of Funko pops to old vintage TV shows merchandise like Power Ranges, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Star Wars, and much more! They are having a big sale, so please come and check it out!”
“Stuff changes every few weeks. Most prices are half of normal. But that's sometimes at least 60% of stock is my guess. I always save when shopping here. Household stuff and some food. Kind of like a small KMart.”
“Professional staff. They take coupons. They have good, affordable products for your child. Contrary to the one in Indianapolis, I will definitely recommend ? this location”
“Took my daughter to get her first ear piercing. Had a awesome experience with Amber and Kristine. They made the process fun, quick and easy for my daughter. They were kind and thoughtful about her comfort. Thank you”
“My baby had left so many clothes many brand new and I was hesitant about bringing in her clothes just because I had heard and read negative things but I went in and everyone was super sweet and the process was so fast! Definitely bringing in more clothes and will be shopping with them as well”
“This place is great, awesome selection and a helpful staff when you inquire for help. They have some meets up and miniature battles a the regular. Totally worth checking out”
“Had my daughters birthday party here. Reasonable price for a bunch of kids for the selection of bears they all got to choose from. There were tons, and not just generic ones. The staff was awesome. I expected a simple shuffle through, but they took the time and had some small events to make the whole thing special. The birthday party here is way more than expected and this staff truly knocked it out of the park on a busy Labor Day weekend.”
“My family and I LOVE The Toy Pit! The staff is always so friendly and helpful. Mark & Mike were so kind today and Their energy alone makes this place worth coming to! Toy Pit has so many collectibles and it's always something new available that you'll love to have im sure.”