Lost Dutchman Rare Coins has been a trusted full-service coin shop in Indianapolis since 1983. Family-run and welcoming, the shop specializes in buying and selling collectible coins, paper money, and bullion. Customers appreciate the friendly atmosphere, as the staff is genuine, knowledgeable, and eager to help. Visitors often note the shop’s warm environment, where browsing is encouraged, and staff members are especially kind to children and novices, fostering a love for the hobby. The staff’s fair and straightforward approach makes buying and selling coins easy, with prices considered reasonable by customers. Many mention the staff’s willingness to go out of their way, including offering advice, recommendations, and even sharing interesting coin stories. The shop also offers collection supplies and provides a pleasant experience for both seasoned collectors and newcomers. Overall, Lost Dutchman Rare Coins is known for its excellent service, fair dealings, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes coin collecting enjoyable for everyone. The shop’s reputation is built on years of trust, friendliness, and a genuine passion for coins and the coin community.
Updated review, all issues have been taken care of, my advice, just go into the store if there’s something you want so there will be no miscommunications.
February 2026
Friendly staff. Straightforward approach. Offers made are fair. You decide what’s right for you. Good selection.
December 2025
Super knowledgeable and friendly staff. Gave a fair price for silverware I inherited and were gracious enough to appraise old coins I wasn’t interested in selling. Lots of cool stuff to look at while you wait! Didn’t feel rushed, and would definitely go back to buy or sell.
