-
October 2025 by Liz C
This is the neatest little candy shop! It's tucked away in a little space on Pearl Street I believe, so cozy and well stocked. Can't wait to go back and try some of the different Oreos. Downtown New Albany shops and the riverfront path are really a great combo. Next time I will come to walk the path, eat some dinner and get a treat at this candy shop!
-
August 2025 by David Bui
Owner is terribly rude, never seen a store run like this, is not well managed at all. Would not recommend at all unless you want to get treated poorly.
-
August 2025 by Eldritch Bee
The owner is rude and incredibly disrespectful. After looking at the reviews I want to say that not every negative review of you or youe employees behavior is harassment and bullying. Your own actions make people feel that way and they are warning others about your behavior. I think you need to take a moment and realize that you need to get your behavior in check if you are going to run a business. This is incredibly unprofessional and childish.
-
August 2025 by Rena Mai
The owner does not seem open to constructive criticism and tends to view negative feedback as bullying or harassment. During our visit, she was rude both to me and to my friend, and there was a past experience where my friend who is over 18 and was simply accompanying children and the owner went as far as asking my friend to leave, despite them following the rules. Which felt unnecessary and unkind. After we left an honest review about our experience, she claimed we were lying. However, what we shared was exactly how we experienced the visit.
-
August 2025 by Brenda Bui
The owner is crazy, she is so rude and absolutely disrespectful
-
August 2025 by Sofia Eback
I don’t recommend this place. The owner went out of their way to be rude to my friends and I and yes, we are 21+.
-
July 2025 by Sarah Choate
Went here for the second time today. They have a large selection of all types of candy. I love their truffles! The shop is decorated so cute and colorfully. I'll have to stop here anytime I'm in New Albany now!
-
June 2025 by Dakota Simkins
Dubai chocolate covered strawberries!! Yasss. All the macrons are amazing. Orange Creamsicle and the Chocolate!! Get you some!! Stevie is an amazing artist. Thank you for your hospitality
-
June 2025 by J Smith
Great selection of high quality homemade chocolates. The owner and her staff are always very helpful.
-
June 2025 by Katie Shelton
I love the Sugar Shoppe! It is such a fun experience to visit their adorable little store and see all the cool sweets and treats! All of the chocolate covered items are my favorite, especially when Stevie gets the opportunity to make her AMAZING Caramel Apples!
-
June 2025 by Maxon Gardner
My wife recently moved to New Albany. We found the Sugar Shoppe due to how bright and festive the shop looked from the outside. The inside is very clean and organized. We have been back several times and taken our son as well. Mrs. Stevie has been amazing. She has always been very welcoming, professional, and fun. She knows her product, and once she knows a person's taste, she can recommend other items that are similar and very good. Many types of salt water taffy, she hand makes some of the chocolate candies (the almond w/english toffee are great!), as well as a huge assortment of gummies, and more. We look forward to visiting quite often in the future!
-
May 2025 by Jarred Parent
The staff and owner are great and wonderful people, really glad to be a loyal and regular for them, their candy and sweets are amazing and very respwctful
-
May 2025 by Kimberly Bartos
This place is absolutely adorable. Decorated in a happy, bright pink color, with fun treats everywhere. The owner greeted us immediately was beyond helpful. We left with a variety of goodies to bring back to MN for the whole family to enjoy. Thank you!
-
April 2025 by Sadie Smiley
Delicious chocolates. Over priced candies. Very weird policies with signs all over the place about how teens aren't welcome.
-
April 2025 by Cole P
Absolutely love this place! The chocolate dipped Oreo cookies are out of the world amazing!!! A must do in New Albany! The owner Stevie is the nicest lady! I would post pics but the cookies didn't last long enough. Will be back for more!
