-
September 2025 by Robert Higsby
I love Casey’s in the north side of jasper
-
August 2025 by Judy Mingus
It's the first time we had been in this store. We heard the pizza was amazing. Well I can officially say it was awesome .
The service was great , he was very nice and informative. The place was clean and very sanitary, it even smelt good. Definitely will be back again. I recommend try the pizza!!♥️
-
August 2025 by Roberta H
I only want to speak about the lack of the fuel stations accommodations! Lack of paper receipts lack of windshield cleansing and over fill of trash cans! C'mon people, what the heck?
-
July 2025 by Adeline Schaeffer
Not a clean store, takes forever to get checked out at the register, always out of everything and they never have lunch at lunch time it’s always breakfast. In the last few months the atmosphere has went down hill so bad I don’t even like going there anymore and I used to go there all the time.
-
June 2025 by BossB*tch
The employees were all friendly and very upbeat & pleasant. They store tends to be on the pricey side but let's face it, it's Santa Claus, everything is over priced here. BUT... I know I will pick this Casey's over the other one on the other end of town any day of the week, because at least they have the prices on their shelves!! The scammy, dishonest sales technique of not marking a single price on anything in the store is a major trigger for me.
-
January 2025 by Beyz 4 Dayz
Great food and friendly staff!! Highly recommend signing up for rewards and recommend the Pizza!! Breakfast or dinner!!
-
January 2025 by Jose Lopez
Lazy workers I came to pay for gas and they were on the phone for 10 minutes and didn’t attend me so I left.
-
October 2024 by Amanda Fultz
We used to come by here after visiting Holiday World, but now we just go to one closer to home, because since the beginning of the 2024 season, they never have any food / pizza available (even when trying to pre-order through the app).
-
August 2024 by Mallory Patel
Just a heads up to anyone who leaves Holiday World after a long day and thinks that Casey’s pizza is available, it’s not. We called an order in at 9pm, paid for it, and when we showed up at the time we were told on our call, we were told they were not making anymore pizzas and they would not process our order. We had already paid and they won’t refund us until their manager comes in the next day. We placed an order (and paid for it!) ONE HOUR before their listed closing time and they refused to make our order. This place is a joke and time should not be wasted here. Just wanted to give warning because it was a major inconvenience and they obviously lie about how late they are open.
-
July 2024 by Felicia Spencer
Went on Saturday right after spending the whole day at Holiday World. We arrived at 945pm hoping for a few slices of pizza and some drinks for our drive back to Evansville. No pizza, waited in line 30 min to checkout. Only 1 cashier and the bathroom was trashed, no toilet paper, trash everywhere outside. Terrible!!!
-
July 2024 by Devon F
Perfect spot for a convenience store. Has good coffee and plenty of snacks. Clean bathroom.
-
March 2024 by Sherry Bauer
Greeted with kindness awsome customer
-
July 2023 by Jessi f
I have no other choice but to give 1 star since I went in for gas & could not get gas. I tried to use 3 differ cards at 2 different pumps but each and every time it would except my payment & everything would work as expected until it would tell me to remove my card. As soon as I removed my card it would say "processing" for FOREVER until I had no other choice but to cancel the transaction. Frustrated, I drove off and got gas somewhere else.
-
July 2023 by Donna D
I stopped to get food after a trip to Holiday World. They were out of most everything, I got wings and they charged me $18 for 16 wings, which I think is ridiculous but prices weren’t posted so shame on me. Then I bought 3 bags of chips clearly labeled for $1.99 per bag. They charged me $2.49. When I complained they yelled at me about how it’s not their fault or problem and there’s nothing they can do about it being mislabeled. Then told me another label was correct (for a different product ) and when I said I wasn’t given that price showed me that it was expired. They then just pulled off the wrong price and said they didn’t have to honor it. I asked to speak to management and Joseph Haynes said that he was the only person there and wouldn’t do anything about it or give me any other contact information.
-
June 2023 by Donna D.
I stopped to get food after a trip to Holiday World. They were out of most everything, I got fresh wings and they charged me $18 for 16 wings, which I think is ridiculous but prices weren't posted so shame on me. Then I bought 3 bags of chips clearly labeled for $1.99 per bag. They charged me $2.49. When I complained they yelled at me about how it's not their fault or problem and there's nothing they can do about it being mislabeled. Then told me another label was correct (for a different product ) and when I said I wasn't given that price showed me that it was expired. They then just pulled off the wrong price and said they didn't have to honor it. I asked to speak to management and Joseph Haynes said that he was the only person there and wouldn't do anything about it or give me any other contact information.
