-
July 2023 by Alicia Gravit
I ordered a pizza and the crust wasn't done. I called and spoke to Caleb five minutes before closing. He was very patient with me and remade my pizza. Honestly best pizza I have ever gotten from Elmo's. Such a respectful young man. I believe he will be an amazing manager some time soon. Thank you Caleb for making us a great pizza! I give him personally ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐!
-
June 2023 by Kevin Napier
There's never food in the warmer during breakfast and if there is it is a pizza or Bosch sticks. I like pizza but I'd rather eat breakfast foods.
-
June 2023 by Kathy Norris
I've been ordering from Elmo's for almost 4 years I have a child with a tomato allergy I have always been able to have the sauce replaced with bosco butter tonight I get my pizza home and guess what there's tomato sauce on it. When I called them they told me they cannot take the sauce off of a pizza and even though I had told them in the instructions that I had a tomato allergy in my home they put freaking tomato sauce on the pizza. So now I get to figure out what to feed a child did I order the specialty pizza for because he can't eat it I get to cook something for dinner when that was the whole point of ordering Elmo's in the first place.
-
November 2022 by Christopher Aguilar
Pizza made right every time,fantastic flavors and genuinely amazing staff.
-
August 2022 by Brian Hodge
Gave wrong pizza to us got home had to go back thay thought it was funny and cussed me out my pizza was cold they gave me will never go back
-
January 2022 by Lisa Marie
Nice convenient lil place , pizzas and subs are good...
-
August 2021 by Chelsea B.
Decent pizza for the cost. Not the most flavorful but the crust was so thin and crispy and that made up for a little lack of seasoning. I would give it another try before a final verdict.
-
June 2021 by Lisa Marie Deavers
Nice convenient lil place , pizzas and subs are good...
-
June 2021 by Nancy P.
I was very pleasantly surprised or should I admit shocked! We are staying on Westler Lake and went out looking for dinner. Presuming it is in season for the lake we thought options would be plentiful. Drove to LaGrange, Walcottville, Rome City and back through Wolcottville heading back to our cottage desperately hungry. Decided since this was about the only option open anywhere we would try, but I was very skeptical of pizza in a gas station. The aroma was very yummy when I went in still on the fence about ordering. I decided after seeing the many waiting in line it must be worth a try. My pizza with pepperoni, sausage, green pepper & onion was actually quite tasty. My dad and I were both glad we stopped. If you want a good carry out meal while at the lakes, this pizza is worth a try. For the $11.99 it was a darn good pizza.
-
August 2020 by Ross
I was given an order of Buffalo Wings by a co-worker and wow...the flavor was exactly as it should be. So now when I think of Wings I think Elmo's. ?
-
August 2020 by Raegan Johnson
I would rate it a 0/5 stars if that was an option. Went to Elmo’s today (08/08/2020) for a breakfast sandwich. I am a vegetarian, so I would not get meat on my sandwich. All I wanted was the classic breakfast sandwich with no meat, so just egg and cheese. The worker and the manager refused to do it. They said I had to get meat on my sandwich. Even after explaining I am a vegetarian, they still refused. I did not ask for a discount on the sandwich, I did not ask for a difficult sandwich. I simply asked them to skip a step by not putting meat on, which would even save them some time. Will not be going back.
-
March 2020 by Corpse of Lena
Mess up my order every single time I come in. Employees are rude.
-
July 2019 by Chrissie Thompson
This place has great pizza AND subs! Always hard to choose which one i want since they are both so good!
-
September 2018 by Don Mackey
great pizza hot and ready
-
July 2018 by Christy B.
Was iffy about pizza from a gas station but was very pleasantly surprised. We got meat pizza and a veggie and they had lots of toppings, the cheese was brown and bubbly and lots of it! Actually better than Cootie Browns and Copper Top.