Casey's is a mixed experience for customers. While some appreciate the friendly staff and the cleanliness of the establishment, others express frustration with the lack of phone service and issues with food orders. Many enjoy the breakfast pizza and find certain employees, like one in a Ravens hat, to be particularly helpful and positive. However, there are complaints about the quality of other pizzas being greasy and occasionally containing hair. Overall, Casey's has its loyal fans but also faces competition due to service shortcomings, like not answering calls and an app-related oversight that caused order confusion.
There was a 2 for 5$ deal on reese’s and twix and the system didn’t pick up on it so the cashier helped us out and got us the deal!! Thank you Brian! He was so personable and kind
December 2025
Slowest pizza makers in town. I'd add 20 mins to your promise time. Probably wise to drive to other side of town. It will be faster and taste better.
May 2023
God i love this place. I always grow a smile in my pants every time I see this good looking fellow Christian. He’s always nice to me, and never seems to be down on his luck. Keep up the good work! Can’t wait to come back.
