Casey's in Sheffield, IA is a good small town store offering pizza with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. It features hot food like sausage and pepperoni pizza slices, plus appetizers, sweet treats like Cookie Dough Bites, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. Customers can also fill up with quality fuels. The store is very clean and organized, and the staff is noted as very nice and friendly. While busy periods can happen, the service is commended. It provides a convenient spot for food, drinks, and everyday needs.
Shout out to Tracy at Casey’s in Sheffield, she makes the best donuts and Brandon makes some bomb pizza!
April 2026
Always consistent. It's pretty good highway food. Hamburgers are very etibl
January 2026
Had one of the coldest sandwich in any gas station ever. It was a little bit warm but much colder than should have been. Definitely need improvement in the Department of Cooking.
