Casey's is a business that offers pizza and coffee. Reviews indicate the pizza can be fantastic, described as amazing, tasty, properly done, and one of the best, with perfect cheese and ample toppings. Some customers feel it is better than some top pizza chains. Both the original and new thin crust receive praise for looking great and tasting even better. The coffee is also highlighted as awesome, with a mind-blowing aroma and taste on-par with Starbucks. However, experiences can vary. While some customers report a great experience with friendly workers and become regulars, others find it a major hit or miss, noting occasional disappointment with items like a taco pizza that had hardly any toppings. Customer service receives mixed feedback. Positive reviews commend staff for being kind, patient, and helpful, with specific appreciation for workers who provide excellent service, even during busy times, by personally ensuring orders are correct. Conversely, a negative experience involved poor service where an employee was uncommunicative and made an error with a coupon. Overall, many customers find visits to Casey's worth it, especially when the food meets its high potential, though consistency in both food quality and service may fluctuate.
Good selection of donuts. Attendant very friendly. Place is clean.
April 2025
Dom really helped me out when I ordered a pizza without cheese or marinara sauce (apparently I cannot use their app). Really appreciated his customer service to make it right as it was a busy night with NCAA tournament on!
March 2024
When Caseys pizza is good, it's hard to beat. This location has consistently good pizza.
