Casey's in Atchison, KS, located at 1629 Main St, is a popular spot offering a variety of services and products. Customers praise its great pizza, which features made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The pizza is described as good and not too greasy, with favorites like pepperoni and supreme. While some find the pizza a bit greasy and sometimes the boxes leak grease, overall, it compares favorably to other local options, especially considering the price. Casey’s also offers hot items like pizza and chicken wings all day into the evening, along with appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, household essentials, and groceries.
The store is consistently kept clean, and staff are generally friendly and helpful. Customers appreciate the polite and attentive employees, especially one who went above and beyond during a power outage to assist a customer, demonstrating excellent service. Gas prices at this location are often lower than nearby competitors, and the store provides quality fuels for fueling up.
However, some frustrations exist with the ordering process. Specials are sometimes only available online, and the store’s app is not very user-friendly, making phone orders easier for some customers. Additionally, while the donut case is usually well-stocked, it often lacks Long John donuts, which some customers crave regularly. Despite these minor issues, Casey’s remains a favored place for good pizza, friendly service, and convenient shopping needs.
We ate at the bar it was a busy weekend. The bartender did a excellent job keeping up with drink orders and food.
July 2026
Some Casey's I've visited drinks are never stocked. I know what I want to drink, so I skip Casey's and go to a station I know always has my drinks stocked.
September 2024
The grossest bathroom I’ve ever seen, luckily I only had to go number one.
