-
February 2024 by Den Usa
This Casey's had lower gas prices than most in the area. We like Casey's because they have good selection of qualityhot items which many C-stores do not. They offer for sale pizza and chicken wings all day and into the evening. We visited here(repeatedly) May 2023.
-
February 2024 by Jonathan Hagans
If Jessica were working by herself today this Casey's would be getting 5 starts from me. 17th and main Atchison is 930 am 01,18,2024 . Unfortunately for this Casey's Tabitha and Lisa were in the store at this time a fuse had blown in the store and a couple of their appliances weren't working size and groans from Tabitha when she had to remove her earbuds from her ear assured me everything was working and went back to work I asked a second time she referred me to Lisa who came out rolling her eyes sighing and grunting she looked around a little bit and I asked her if she knew the breaker box was she said not right now I don't and walked away Jessica who was working the cash register and already busy who is extra polite when I came in and tentative to my needs when there was no customers broke away from her station to remedy the problem I'm headed to work and I appreciate Jessica and her going above and beyond not only her job duties but the duties of Lisa who I'm guessing is a manager and the cook who is too busy jamming out to her earbuds to help a customer.
-
December 2023 by Gavin Tate
I live about 20 minutes away from this Casey's, so I order my pizza before I leave the house, and everytime we get here we have to wait for the pizza to be made, I would understand if we didn't pay for it until we got there, but we pay when we order and we still have to wait for it to be made.
-
December 2022 by Mark L.
Ordered through the Casey's app- apparently door dash brings that order - forgot cookies and marinara sauce - called store - refused to do anything about it and said I had to call door dash - again did not order through door dash.
-
November 2022 by Horace J.
In light of the fact that Gambino's is so weak, I guess I will be on the Casey's wagon for awhile. Their pizza is a little too greasy and grease always leaks through their boxes. But the pizza is pretty good and as of today, much better than Gambino's. (Also, of the price!) The one thing I dislike about Casey's is that often their specials are only available by ordering on-line. That would be OK if their app was more user friendly but it's not! Ordering is SO much simpler if you can call in on the phone!
-
October 2022 by Clare R.
I ordered a 8 piece traditional wings with buffalo and garlic Parmesan sauce. The wings were raw, rubbery and not cooked. I called to see if i could get a refund and I was put on hold, and never was helped. I called 3 times after that and no one answered. terrible customer service.
-
June 2022 by Christopher C.
I always love their pepperoni pizza, not too greasy and just the right amount of pepperoni. Also tried their supreme which was just as good!
-
May 2022 by Kari Wolters
We are so limited in Atchison, but I won't be ordering from here again. I spent $25 and absolutely everything was cold and over cooked. I only ate a half of the tenderloin because I was hungry and it was the least horrid of the whole order. Just simply awful. Sorry I couldn't give it 0 stars.
-
March 2022 by Katie Barlow
Overall a clean Casey’s. Their store is always clean and everyone is always nice. The reason I rate a 4 is because I’ve craved long John donuts my whole pregnancy and I think I’ve only been able to get them like 6 times my whole pregnancy. Every time I go into this Casey’s their donut case is normally full with every other donut but the long Johns. So what I would change is how often they put long johns in their donut case. Other than that it’s a great store. ☺️
-
October 2021 by J D
??"Awesome store!!!"... Love their pizza!!!... If you order Casey's pizza it's because you've had it before and know great pizza... If you haven't well your missing out!!!
-
August 2021 by Lisa M.
Ordered a taco pizza (the best) from Casey's! We picked it up hot and fresh! We got it home and wowza! I didn't eat the whole thing, I was tempted! My only suggestion would be to put the chips on the side and let us put it on at home so it doesn't get soggy! In addition, if there are leftovers I can put them in myself the next day! If you've never had a Casey's pizza you are missing out on some yummy goodness!
-
June 2021 by richard dickinson
I order 2x a week and every time you run out of stuff how does they run out catsup packs???iorder a salad and get it with out what I asked or blk olive or cheese I pay for stuff I do not get I ready to order from another. Place
-
January 2021 by Glen Buckley
Clean, organized and maybe the friendliest staff in town
-
December 2020 by Aisha Mitchell
Always clean. One of my favorite aspects of the Casey's chain is that they always have free air! Most of them even have a tire gauge inside that you can use upon request.
-
December 2020 by Vincent Sprinkle
Best pizza ever and always there when I need a break from the road.