FYE Hagerstown offers a large and impressive selection of movies, music, collectibles, and unexpected products, creating a strong sense of nostalgia. The store carries a wide variety of options, including new and used DVDs, with some cheap DVD options noted. However, multiple reviews criticize the prices as being very high, even stupidly so, with some items lacking price stickers. The staff is described as friendly. Overall, it is a place that brings back memories but is often considered expensive.
Overpriced and dying store with terrible layout changes recently. Looks like it could close any day.
December 2025
Nice selection of items, but very overpriced, especially when it comes to collectibles. Almost everything in here is double the cost compared to anywhere else.
May 2025
Usually when I'm at the mall I'll stop in FYE to have a look at the movies. I always find at least two or three I dont have at a fair price.
