The Chatham Penny Candy Store offers a nostalgic trip down memory lane, filled with classic candy treats from the 50s, 60s, and 70s. While the selection may be limited and the prices slightly higher, the store provides a charming, old-fashioned experience, especially for children. The staff is known for their patience and the store remains a highlight for many families who enjoy the unique atmosphere and the opportunity to indulge in their favorite childhood candies.
A must stop in Chatham for a sweet experience.. the ice cream was a great topper 😀
August 2026
We have gone to this candy shop for many years and love it! This year, I am now strictly gluten free. When I asked the owner what was gluten free, he asked what I wanted. He then proceeded to pull out every bag from the back to allow me to check the ingredients. I am so appreciative of his kindness.
July 2026
The salt water taffy was very soft and fresh. Best salt water taffy I've ever had. Staff were courteous. I did not try fudge or ice cream.
