Hotels in Edgartown, MA

“Lovely hotel in an excellent location close to the heart of Edgartown. Very pleasant decoration and atmosphere. the bedroom, breakfast area and lounge were all immaculately clean. Friendly and professional service from all the staff.”

“I had such a wonderful stay at The Richard in Edgartown! From the moment I arrived, the staff’s friendliness made me feel so welcome. The inn has a cozy, inviting atmosphere that feels both stylish and comfortable. One of my favorite touches was the fresh baked goods offered throughout the day—the sweet potato scones were absolutely amazing!

The location is also perfect—right in downtown Edgartown with shops and restaurants just steps away, and less than a three-minute walk to the shuttle that takes you directly to Oak Bluffs. It made exploring the island so easy and stress-free.

If you’re looking for a warm, charming place to stay with thoughtful details and a truly convenient location, The Richard is a fantastic choice. I can’t wait to return!”

“Perfect location and has super friendly staff. The food was amazing and the property is tough to beat. The view from the balcony rooms to the courtyard with the pool is magical. Also, the hotel lobby smells incredible. Please make a candle of your lobby scent because I will happily purchase 3.”

“We had an amazing stay! Exceeded our expectations. 1. The room was very nice and I enjoyed the time spent on the Balcony sunbathing & stargazing. 2. Breakfast was light & delicious. They left cookies for guests in the afternoon as well. 3. Service was impeccable. Host tried her best to accommodate an early check in which we really appreciated. 4. Location super convenient”

“Martha’s Vineyard so precious and I was very privileged to stay at one of the best resort in the island. Everything - room interior, service, food, nature - is so perfect that I understood why people pay a lot of dollars to stay here during peak July/August.I heard that the former president often visit here with many celebrities and this resort recently hosted his famous 60th birthday party.I will definitely revisit if I get another opportunity to visit the island.Rooms: Ocean view rooms are breathtakingSafety: The resort area seems to be very safe. I do not have problem walking around the resort at midnight for stargazing.Food & drinks: There’s a restaurant called the Dunes inside the resort and the culinary team is very competent. Highly recommend.”

“We absolutely LOVED our stay at the Sydney, The location was so close to all the stores, restaurants and sights you want to see in Edgartown. Everything is a short walking distance. Yet once in the hotel, you felt like it was a lovely oasis. The rooms were clean, comfortable and beautiful and the bathrooms were perfect. There is a lovely courtyard where you can relax and eat the breakfast they serve or just hangout. And in the evening they have a fire pit. The service was great! We felt very well taken care of. I would highly recommend staying here if visiting Martha’s Vineyard.”

“I just spent a long weekend at Hobnob, my first visit to Martha’s Vineyard, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From the moment I checked in, Abby at the front desk made me feel right at home with her warm hospitality and genuine kindness. Her welcome set the tone for what turned into an unforgettable stay.

The property itself is adorable and quaint, with a perfect location that’s hard to beat. It’s easy to walk to Edgartown’s downtown area—just a few blocks to amazing restaurants, cozy bars, coffee shops, bookstores, and charming shops. The rooms are decorated beautifully and feel thoughtfully curated, with colors and decor that are cozy and inviting. The beds were incredibly comfortable!!

But the real standout was the staff. Everyone seemed genuinely dedicated to making our weekend special. The breakfast each morning was fantastic—fresh, tasty, and a great way to start our days. On one beach day, the hotel went above and beyond by packing us scones and water bottles, which was such a thoughtful touch.

Another fantastic amenity is the beach gear Hobnob offers—chairs, umbrellas, and coolers available for borrow. It made our beach days effortless and enjoyable without the extra hassle of renting gear or bringing it from home.

If you’re considering a stay on Martha’s Vineyard, I highly recommend Hobnob. It feels like a home away from home, with a touch of luxury and a lot of heart. I’m already planning my next visit and can’t imagine staying anywhere else—the staff truly treats you like family, and I’m so grateful for my stay. You’ll want to come back too.”

“We had a great visit to the Harborside Inn. Everything was beautiful especially the landscaped grounds. Staff was welcoming and helpful. Location can’t be beat for convenience. Definitely plan to return!”

“The Kelly House is a wonderful place!
The staff, grounds and accommodations were stupendous! We might decide to make this wonderful place a routine visit in October every year♥️”

“Visited from Scotland several days ago with my husband and kids and my sister and stayed for 2 nights as part of a holiday including NY and Salem and I have to say this was our favourite hotel by far. We booked a family room and a separate double room for my sister and both rooms were clean, modern and comfortable. Staff at the front desk were friendly and approachable and the location was ideal for exploring the island. Overall I would rate this hotel highly and we are very much hoping to return some time in the future. Thank you for a wonderful stay.”