Jewelry Stores in Nantucket, MA

17 locations found near Nantucket

“I was walking around Nantucket with my family. We were walking, looking for a jewelry store because I needed a ring size for a state championship baseball ring that I would like to get through the school. When I walked in the store, I had no intention of buying anything. I just wanted to get my ring size. I asked the kind owner at the store, and sure enough she offered to size my finger. Thank you so much! I will definitely be back! Awesome customer service!”

4.9 Superb54 Reviews

“I was on vacation in Nantucket and my favorite necklace got terribly tangled. I called Pageo Jewlwers hoping they might be able to help, even though I hadn’t purchased my necklace there. The staff couldn’t have been kinder—they took the time to carefully untangle it right on the spot and didn’t charge me a thing. Their kindness and professionalism really stood out and made my day. If I’m ever in the market for jewelry while I’m in town again, this will be my first stop. Highly recommend!”

4.7 Superb38 Reviews

“First time in Nantucket. Walked into this shop, saw a stunning ring, said I was going to shop around and that i might be back. Couldn't find anything that i loved more so i found my way back. Bought a beautiful silver ring w acid etching and a centered pearl. Really cute place! Lots of beautiful choices. Was fortunate to meet Victoria herself ~ lovely lady. Will visit again!”

4.9 Superb18 Reviews

“If there was one shop I’d say was worth visiting on the Island it would be here. The craftsmanship is beautiful. Even if you walk away without making a purchase, you will still be able to admire the artistic work behind everything on display.”

4.6 Superb21 Reviews

“I shop at Nalu whenever I'm on island, and the staff and owner are always lovely and so helpful. The goods are really well curated and well-considered for a broad customer base. Thanks for keeping a gorgeous storefront open and fostering a great shopping experience!”

4.4 Superb20 Reviews

“What a beautiful store with many great things we purchased a few items there that we will cherish for a long time chatted with the store owner very nice person. I wish them every success and love everything they had in the store.”

4.4 Superb16 Reviews

“The best!! Truly a nantucket mainstay, I've been coming for years and every time leave with so many incredible finds. I send all island visitors looking for cute clothes or needlepoints here. The people working there are also so great and helpful!”

4.1 Good59 Reviews

“Delightful store! Always something wonderful to find in this elegantly curated boutique!
Beautiful European linens and unique items for gifting at a great range of prices.
Very warm and welcoming owner and staff like Kiki!”

5 Superb5 Reviews

“Susan and her team are wonderful. It was my husband’s and mines first time visiting Nantucket. She
made us feel at ease and made our experience super special. She helped me pick out my mini Moby charm. I will cherish it forever. When you are in town make sure you visit her store. It is worth the trip!”

5 Superb5 Reviews

“This store is AMAZING! A must go to in nantucket. The man helping my mother and I was so kind and helpful. We chit chatted and he made the experience so wonderful. The clothes are such good quality and so flattering. 10/10!!”

4.5 Superb8 Reviews

“I own only a couple of pieces of Reuben’s jewelry, but every time I walk into his shop I always wish I had a billion dollars. Everything,and I do mean everything, is breathtaking. His designs are so original, you won’t see them in every shop, and you will always feel special wearing them.”

5 Superb4 Reviews

“The Gallery is beautiful. Greg's art is great, we have several originals and prints. Judi's Pearl's are also wonderful, Pam, her friend is an artist and learned her skills in the Far East. This is a great gallery and the atmosphere is very welcoming. Great artists.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“Over the last 17 years, I have bought beautiful and unique items from The Jewelers' Gallery, as gifts for every occasion requiring the highest quality work in gold. The owner and sales staff have always been friendly, welcoming, patient, and knowledgeable. They've earned my loyalty ever time I've been in the gallery, and so well deserve my highest recommendation.”

4.2 Good6 Reviews

“Great designer selection. Fabulous sale area upstairs. The owner and team are exceptional and know how to style their customers. Please open a shop in Carmel California!!”

4.2 Good4 Reviews

“I have been in this store twice in the last four years and both times I loved the selection of clothing and accessories. I found the staff, especially during this year’s visit in July (2026) very patient, helpful, and pleasant. I think the layout of this new location makes it easier for shoppers to browse and for staff to see who needs them. A lovely store with very nice staff.”

3.4 Good9 Reviews

“Barbara has access to gems of incredible quality and creates beautiful and unique jewelry with them. Her creations are wearable works of art. I always feel joyful when I am wearing one of her pieces. She also applies her exquisite taste to sourcing elegant accessories created by skilled artisans. Walking into her lovely shop is a wonderful treat!”

3 Average4 Reviews