Buffalo Exchange is described as the best location, a treasure trove and a well-curated fashion boutique that feels like the wardrobe at Vogue. Reviewers highlight its great and excellent selection, noting it is neatly organized with a fabulous store credit system and unbeatable prices. The staff is consistently noted as remarkably friendly, very kind, welcoming, helpful, and patient, with genuine interest in assisting customers. The selling process is praised as refreshingly painless, with staff clearly explaining the payout process; sellers report successfully selling most or all of the clothes they brought in, including designer items. The management and sales team are commended for their firm grip on fashion, understanding quality materials, designs, brand histories, and iconic pieces, not just trends. While one reviewer mentions the presence of fast fashion and prefers this location to another, the overall sentiment is extremely positive. Customers express that it was one of their best thrifting hauls, they found pieces they wear to death, and they absolutely adore their new items. They are big fans, can’t wait to return, and only regret not living closer, wishing more people knew about this store.
The buyers here have great taste! Lots of linens, leathers, and silks at good prices.
July 2026
Great store with great prices and friendly staff. New stuff comes in every day so it’s always fun to come back and find hidden gems 💫
June 2026
This is such a well curated store; it's always fun to go in. Prices can be on the high side but if you're looking for really memorable, unique pieces, it's a great stop. On this most recent visit we got excellent styling help from June. Her recs helped us build a killer outfit on a tough theme!
