-
May 2024 by Maggie Tanner
I love that Caffrey's has online ordering and delivery. The delivery is cheap and usually fast! Their coleslaw is really good and if you get the cookies when they're still fresh/soft; they're to die for! The delivery people have always been friendly. The actual sandwiches are good, not going to blow your socks off, but it's always consistently "good". Bread is always soft and fresh
-
April 2024 by KTM
A neighborhood staple. Protect Caffreys at all costs..
-
April 2024 by Kayla Perry
Been coming here for years. Always make time to stop by when Im in town and grab a sammy.
-
April 2024 by Tara Walden
Omg forever fave! Blue cow sandwich psssst be sure to ask for red cherry pepper relish! Pete is the real deal and so happy he is just himself with good products. Fun fact I've been eating their sandwiches for years. I felt off one day and decided to order - we literally found out that I was pregnant because I couldn't stomach my favorite sandwich here! ?
-
April 2024 by Paul Graslewicz
I was a returning customer and thought I’d treat myself to a 25 dollar sandwich. It was aweful and the service people were rude and acted like I was a nuisance for entering. Too bad. I’ve had good experiences there in the past.
-
April 2024 by William “Willis” Klatt
Underrated, this place is 5 stars in my book and in the book if anyone who knows anything about food. They’re fast, everything is made from scratch. Nothing, NOTHING misses its mark on this menu. Eat here, tip well.
-
April 2024 by Alec Hansen
5 stars for every single reply from Pete Caffrey. I'm reading all of them & dying from laughter, my sides hurt!Used to party in Uptown, get wasted, and hit Caffrey's at like 3am if I remember correctly. I also think there used to be a hot meatball sandwich on the menu that was amazing. Gotta check the place out again, sooner rather than later. Glad to see you guys are still making sandwiches!
-
March 2024 by Natalie Webster
Try the grilled cheese , you won’t regret it ?
-
March 2024 by Robin Martin
Their subs are what I've been missing here as a Chicago transplant. LOVE the Lake Street Italian and Vegetable Sandwiches exactly as they are made. The Italian sub dressing is sooooo delicious. Ingredients were fresh and tasty. Only criticism would be next time I think I will have them deliver because it is kind of a pain to park over there, and they weren't the friendliest when I placed my order over the phone and picked up. I have read that's typical though for this place. I don't care what their attitude is- I love the food enough that I will be back.
-
March 2024 by Michael Ferranti
WORST Customer Service EVER !! I came in with 2 friends on Saturday. The tattooed dude taking our order (on register) was angry that we were taking our time trying to order. He was rushing us and spoke badly about us to his 'coworker' who was the 'sandwich maker' dude. He was ever worse. He got 2 of our orders wrong, as we watched him sloppily make our sandwiches. And got angry at me for asking him to put 1 slice of cheese and NO dressing on my $12 dollar sandwich !! I live in the neighborhood and I am on the board. I will make others aware that this is NOT tolerated and they should not be the 'face' of Caffrey's. I will never go back, sadly !!!
-
March 2024 by Elaine Weiss
Loaded Philly is super
-
March 2024 by Gerard Mc
Food was meh. Got the Caesar wrap and it has a weird after taste wouldn’t recommend. Portion was also really small for the price. Couple of croutons thrown in a mostly empty wrap lol. The “what do you want ?” service didn’t phase me as I come from using nyc delis. This place has tons of good reviews so maybe I just came on an off day ??♂️
-
February 2024 by Sherry Knutson
Great food and fast delivery.
-
February 2024 by Christian Marschel
Amazing subs for a reasonable price.
-
February 2024 by Wes Huntington
My wife and I just ordered from here via DoorDash for the first time and I have to say we were really impressed. The subs we ordered were amazing! 10 out of 10 - highly recommend.
