American Gothic Antiques is a beloved antique store located in Stillwater, known for its vast collection of unique and intriguing items. As an avid animal lover's paradise, the store is filled with an abundance of figurines and Beanie Babies, all available at great prices.
Described as a large two-story establishment, the store offers a diverse array of antiques to browse, ranging from vintage lunchboxes and comics to old board games and Beanie Babies. While some visitors have reported a peculiar, possibly supernatural, presence within the store, particularly on the second floor, the overall experience is one of wonder and discovery.
Customers praise the store's excellent customer service and good pricing, with one reviewer even describing it as one of the top three best antique stores they've ever visited. Despite the occasional challenges, such as the lack of air conditioning in the older building, regulars continue to enjoy the thrill of unearthing hidden treasures within the store's extensive collection.
Whether you're in search of a rainy-day adventure or simply an antique lover's paradise, American Gothic Antiques is a must-visit destination, offering a truly unique and memorable shopping experience.
Staff was very helpful, helped me carry things downstairs, wrapped them nicely in paper AND brought to my vehicle. Very impressed! Their store had a great assortment. Like any, have to look around a bit to see what you’re looking for!
July 2026
Great place, friendly and very competent personnel
June 2025
Large variety of items. Browsing is fun and you never know what you will find.
