very friendly and attentive employees. the slice i had was delicious - only issues were it was a little heavy on the cheese and sat a little too long. the prices are super reasonable. would stop in
February 2024
I stopped by the other day ordered a slice.. went to pay the guy wanted $4.79 for a scrawny little slice. New York City prices in Califon.. great.
January 2024
Love the NY WRAP!! But you forgot the fresh mozzarella again!!! 2nd time!I still liked it though!!
Nicola's Pizza is the place to go if you are craving pizza. Offering homemade Italian fare, Nicola's pizza is not only tasty, but the slices are huge. Custom order a pie to your liking, and add on a side of the yummy wings. Feeling guilty? We also offer a variety of salads. Dine-in, carry-out, and delivery are all available here.
