-
March 2024 by Seth Hickenbottom
Very good pizza! Never had a problem with the service, usually pretty quick and if you order ahead it's often ready even a lil early which is great. No frills for sure, but the pizza itself is pretty killer.Parking: It's a small lot but it's never been full in my experience.
-
March 2024 by Aidan Pereira
very friendly and attentive employees. the slice i had was delicious - only issues were it was a little heavy on the cheese and sat a little too long. the prices are super reasonable. would stop in
-
February 2024 by Scott Avery
I stopped by the other day ordered a slice.. went to pay the guy wanted $4.79 for a scrawny little slice. New York City prices in Califon.. great.
-
January 2024 by Brenna Stanley
decided to try this place out on doordash for the first time and let me just say the food was a complete soggy, cold, nasty disappointment. my wife and i ordered the capri paninis and alfredo pasta. her panini was literally just chicken and it was dry and flavorless missing all of the ingredients. mine had chicken and mushrooms and cheese, still missing the basil and fresh mozzarella. i didn’t even eat mine. waste of money. the fries were freezing cold and soggy. we also asked for a side of dressing but that wasn’t given. the pasta was the only thing tolerable but again it was cold and lacked any flavor. overall pretty nasty. also no utensils. won’t be eating here again.
-
January 2024 by Pamela Hoy
Love the NY WRAP!! But you forgot the fresh mozzarella again!!! 2nd time!I still liked it though!!
-
January 2024 by NEWARK BRICKS
DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE! WORST PLACE EVER TO DO BUSINESS! THEY ARE A SCAM. Placed an order off of doordash which was only one hot sub sandwich, said my order was about to be ready in 3 minutes just to get told from doordash that they canceled my order because they "closed" yet this was at 8:30pm and they are open til 10pm. They are unethical and not a good honest place to get food from. They take your money and split. This place should be shutdown if you ask me. I'll take my business elsewhere.
-
December 2023 by Margret Schaefer
I stopped in tonight to order a salad to go. It’s 20 minutes before they close, but they told me they’re already done for the night and they can’t serve me.Thanks, I won’t be back.
-
December 2023 by Phil Fantozzi
I been going to Nicole’s for years now. We mostly ordered their pizza and cheese steaks sandwiches. The quality is very good and the best pizza in Hunterdon County. They are always prompt , friendly and prompt having the food ready.
-
December 2023 by Yoon Lee
Wait over two hours for my order through Slice. Called both Slice and the restaurant who said they were on their way. Finally came after 3 hours total and I refused delivery. Slice charged me stating I had food delivered. When I disputed with Slice, they told me the restaurant delivered the food and I would be charged.Went through credit card company to do a chargeback to get my money back.If you would have been upfront that it would take that long, I would have come to pick it up. It’s a small community and you’re alienating all the residents.
-
November 2023 by Jonathan k
Good pizza and pasta dishes.
-
October 2023 by Ed Rich
Very good food. Had cheese steak and sausage hot sub. Ate it all. Clean environment and friendly staff.
-
September 2023 by North Hunterdon
Delivery drivers always scam us when we get a delivery. They never have change, hoping you give them a big bill. Happens soo much, this time I just sent the food back. Another absentee owner business going down the drain.
-
August 2023 by joey gees
Italian store didn’t know what an iltalian sandwich was I was
-
June 2023 by Chris Doyle
Pizza joint that serves slices. I like the variety.
-
May 2023 by Scott Coppeto
Hadn't been here in a while. Good slice. Quick. Yummy. Always on the list if in the