Jewelry Stores near Eatontown, NJ

“We came in during our vacation trip. We met Don the gentleman behind the counter. He was so welcoming and a wealth of knowledge and charm. He was very accommodating to our search and requests. We purchased a few megladon teeth for our collection at Earth Treasures. I completely appreciated the kindness and education we were given during our visit. If you are looking for GREAT pricing and free knowledge go see Mr. Don. They have museum displays and a gazillion in store options to choose from. I will definitely be back and 100% recommend this business to anyone looking for fossils and wonderful people to do business with.”

“Great experience here yesterday with Lori & Valerie getting our wedding bands! We came in with a pretty clear idea of what we wanted and Lori helped us zero in on the perfect rings so quickly. Very easy and positive experience, so glad we came here!”

“J Vincent Jewlers is an exceptional jewelry store. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful, making it easy to find a special piece for yourself or a loved one. They are skilled designers who can create custom pieces and even go out of their way to find special or rare diamonds for special occasions. I’ve had wonderful experiences with J Vincent Jewlers and will always choose them for my jewelry needs. I would give them more than 5 stars if it were possible.”

“Stopped in to have some jewelry repaired and wow! We found a true GEM! Everyone was so knowledgable, kind, honest and understanding of the memories some of the pieces held and did a beautiful job with all the repairs. I look forward to working with them in the future!”

“Joe and his associates are the nicest people. I needed a new chain for a Medic alert bracelet. He got right into searching for a replacement chain. Joe was very happy to help and found what turned out to be the perfect chain. Thank you Joe.”

“When I was shopping for my wife’s Rolex 26MM two tone with a champagne diamond dial and custom diamond bezel, I was referred to a well known social media jeweler who promotes himself as honest and transparent. To make sure I was getting the best value and quality, I also reached out to Mark from ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches.

The difference was clear.

Mark has been consistent since the first time I worked with him six years ago. He is professional, patient, and incredibly detail oriented. He takes the time to answer every question, explain everything clearly, and guide you through the process without any pressure. Most importantly, he listens and genuinely cares about getting it right.

Since this was my wife’s first Rolex, I wanted everything to be exactly how she envisioned it. Mark and his team were extremely accommodating and made sure every detail was right.

In the end, the decision was easy. We chose Mark and ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches for their exceptional service, top tier quality, and the best value. The entire experience was smooth, transparent, and stress free. You are not just buying jewelry, you are working with someone who truly acts as your advisor.

On top of that, I was able to use my reward points from previous purchases to get my wife a pair of diamond earrings, which made the experience more meaningful. Being able to earn and apply points toward future pieces makes the overall experience more rewarding.

This was truly a win-win, and we are beyond satisfied. I highly recommend Mark and ItsHot Diamond Jewelry & Watches to anyone looking for quality, trust, and a great overall experience.

Thank you again, Mark. I appreciate you and your team.

Best regards,
An”

“Walter Bauman Jewelers is an exceptional jewelry store with an incredible selection and outstanding customer service. From the moment I walked in, everyone made me feel welcome and valued.

A special thank you to Theresa, who was knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely helpful throughout the entire shopping experience. She took the time to understand what I was looking for and made the process enjoyable and stress-free.

I also want to thank my friend Sarah for helping me with my jewelry shopping and making the experience even more fun and memorable.

If you’re looking for beautiful jewelry and a team that truly cares about its customers, I highly recommend Walter Bauman Jewelers. I’ll definitely be back!

EJ Winn”

“Fantastic jewelers. You need to come here. Prices are very competitive and customer service is outstanding. See Remon, he is so patient and extremely helpful. If they don’t have what you want, they will get it or they will make it. I was extremely pleased with the entire experience. I will definitely be a return customer.”

“Obsessed with my ring and this team!! Emily and her team at Jewelry by the Sea were absolutely incredible to work with. Not only did I have no real idea about what engagement ring I wanted but my fiance wanted it for an upcoming trip, 3 weeks later!!
Emily helped me understand my options, talk through the best ring to hold my diamond, and got everything done in that short time. The details are stunning. I needed a small tweak to the size when I returned and they were quick to assist. They want to make sure I'm happy and comfortable. (it's just a tad big, like a. 0001 of a mm). Emily also appraised my ring quickly to ensure we got insurance before our trip.
She was a dream to work with and I will continue to go back for all of my jeweler needs! Thank you so much!!”

“Jen and Ian were great to work with on a custom project. The design process was fun and the end result is fantastic. Happy to bring a family heirloom stone back to life in a one of a kind design! I highly recommend The Art Of Jewelry.”

“From the moment I walked into Wolf Fine Jewelers, Scott and Leandra made me feel like family. They lead with integrity, honesty, and genuine care, which made the entire experience truly special.
They designed the most stunning custom engagement ring I could have imagined and guided me through every step of the process, patiently answering all of my questions along the way. Their attention to detail and commitment to excellence really set them apart.
On top of that, the atmosphere is incredible
You’re welcomed into the store with coffee or even a glass of champagne.
Wolf Fine Jewelers truly goes above and beyond. I can’t thank Scott and Leandra enough for everything they’ve done.”

“I’d like to thank Johnsen Diamond for being the business they are.
It’s not often that you walk into a business and are treated as well as you are there.
They keep the store immaculate. They carry a huge variety of Jewelry including watches which is my favorite piece of Jewelry.
The no pressure approach that they have is very refreshing. I enjoyed being able to browse and when I was ready to start seeing stuff they were courteous and endearing. Imagine that a place not mentioning money within the first few minutes.
I’ve been in the store a couple of times and I’ve called a few times. Always being treated with respect.
I live in Freehold and there are many jewelers between my home and Little Silver NJ. For me they are the only jeweler I will do business with as long as I’m around.
I don’t want to play favorites so I will say that whoever you have assisting you I’m sure you will feel the same way I do. Completely satisfied.
Their Jewelry is beautiful. It’s worth the trip.
Thank You to Robert and the staff”

“First time there was highly recommended by a good friend and I can see why. Very nice and explained everything to me about how my ring was going to be sized without any problems. Very happy with the turnout and I will definitely go back with any jewelry repairs and to buy jewelry, watch repairs and batteries. Will highly recommend”

“I’m so happy I found Gemcraft Jewelers! Tommy repaired my engagement and wedding rings. He then made a diamond and sapphire eternity ring from my rarely worn necklace. It is gorgeous and I now I wear it every day! He is very talented and such a nice guy and I highly recommend him”

“Alan was great! He was prompt in responding.easy to work with. Walked you through the process of what need to be done. Also had called to say my original diamond, looked like it was under the weight that it had been assessed at. Called back immediately afterwards that it actually was correct. He was very very good.”

“Updated Review. Previously left a lower review than need be. After two years of having my wife engagement ring there seem to be some small issues with the ring. I called Sean and let him know the issues. Sean's response was the following and I dont know if anyone could have been better. 1. Here is a fed ex label to overnight the ring back to us. 2. Renovated the ring at no cost to me. 3. Followed up with calls, emails, and pictures. 4. Did all of this when he didn't have too.I highly recommend this shop. Not only do they make the most beautiful jewelry, but their customer service 2 years after purchasing a ring from them has been unparalleled. Thank you Sean and team.”

“I came in to have some necklaces untangled and the two women working were so incredibly kind and helpful. It took them all day to untangle my necklaces—can’t express how greatful I am for their hard work!”

“The staff at the Jersey Shore Premium Outlets, Lana, Catherin, Angela and Emily are amazing! They work together as a team and are superstars! Beyond friendly, professional, knowledgeable and respectful ladies. They all went the extra mile to make our experience exceptional. Corporate should most definitely acknowledge them, especially monetarily - those ladies deserve a well earned raise! Once again I thank them and appreciate them for the extraordinary service!!”

“steven at east cost coin and jewelry exchange is a very nice guy from the first time i went there
both times i found very nice costume jewelry and he worked with me on the price to give me a great value for what i bought and great service
highly recommended”

“Completed a large multi-session back piece with Dave Shoemaker. Experience was great from start to finish. Dave took his time to create a custom freehand Traditional Japanese piece added to an existing Kanji tattoo. I felt comfortable providing feedback about what I wanted from the design and we spoke through elements that were incorporated. He made sure I was confident and comfortable through the whole tattooing process. The shop was very clean, all the staff and other tattoo artists were friendly. My partner even started getting work done by another Ninth Wave artist Fran after my positive experience with the shop.”

“Great customer service. Had some of my silver jewelry dipped in gold. Reasonable pricing and fast service. UPDATE: have had numerous pieces made - exceptional work! I am so happy with his work and overall customer service! I highly trust this jeweler (Carlos) and would recommend!”

“Walter Bauman Jewelers is an exceptional jewelry store with an incredible selection and outstanding customer service. From the moment I walked in, everyone made me feel welcome and valued.

A special thank you to Theresa, who was knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely helpful throughout the entire shopping experience. She took the time to understand what I was looking for and made the process enjoyable and stress-free.

I also want to thank my friend Sarah for helping me with my jewelry shopping and making the experience even more fun and memorable.

If you’re looking for beautiful jewelry and a team that truly cares about its customers, I highly recommend Walter Bauman Jewelers. I’ll definitely be back!

EJ Winn”

“I just had the best experience with Amanda and her wonderful father at Nationwide Gold and Estate Buyers in Spring Lake. I had inherited a large amount of jewelry from my sweet grandma, and they both welcomed me with open arms, and made me feel so comfortable and at ease in their office. They went through everything (and there was a lot) with a fine tooth comb, and took such great care with my grandma’s jewelry. It really meant so much to me. I never felt pressured for a moment, and I know my grandmother would have been so happy that I went to them. This was such a wonderful experience, and I would recommend Amanda to any of my friends and family. Thank you so much for your help!”

“The best staff! So friendly and knowledgeable. They aren't there to rip you off either. If you need any help with watches or fine jewelry, don't go anywhere else! Simply the best and amazing customer service!”

“In February I took my vintage 1665 Sea Dweller to Leonardo's for service. I was informed that it would have to go to the Rolex Service Center for evaluation for service. Leo spoke to Rolex and explained that I did not want the face or hands changed. After 6 weeks called, said they would service it, and get a new bracelet, and not change the face, hands or polish the case. It came back this week and is exactly as requested and looks great.
Leonardo's staff is excellent and helpful. I highly recommend them.

S.Wrigley”

“I have stopped by several times in the past year, for a watch battery, getting a ring prong fixed and getting a new clasp for my necklace. Whatever I needed, everyone was very helpful and friendly.”

“I was buying a necklace there a few days ago and The staff was really nice and kind. He knew I was Irish from Dublin so we were just chatting and having fun. That’s important in life.”

“I have made 3 purchases since June 2, 2014. Their prices are great and customer service even more so. They shipped out a bracelet when I realized I should have ordered a smaller size. I called to let them know and they were happy to give me an exchange - no problem. They sent me a prepaid RMA and I am looking forward to receiving the replacement. I am 100% satisfied and will continue buy from them when the need arises. I would highly recommend them.”

“I received a beautiful charm from my son to add to my bracelet or necklace, but since I hadn’t worn them in a while, they had completely tarnished. I decided to stop by Pandora to have them cleaned so I could finally wear my new charm.

It was a very, very, very cold evening at the Jersey Shore Outlets, and I had trouble finding the store. I called, and immediately was greeted with compassion and kindness as they helped guide me right to the location.

Once inside, I received absolutely amazing customer service from Litzy and Kelly. My necklace, bracelet, and charms where completely cleaned until they were sparkling like new. On top of that, they helped me select a few new items I absolutely loved.

From start to finish, it was a wonderful experience. Exceptional service, warmth on a freezing night, and jewelry that looks brand new again. Highly recommend!”

“I couldn't be happier with the service I received from Sally at Nat's. I went there to get my Mother's wedding ring repaired and watch batteries. Sally was the nicest person and I love giving locally owned proprietors my business. Highly recommend.”