Toy Stores near Edgewater, NJ

30 locations found near Edgewater

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 493 River Rd, Edgewater NJ 07020

    3.2 Average 33 reviews

    “The stores service is GREAT, everyone is chill and polite. If you ask a for a worker to help you with something, chances are they might help you. Overall a great store, also big thanks to Roy, he’s a good guy he helped me get something I needed and is also a great guy.”

  2. 636 5th Ave, New York NY 10020

    4.8 Superb 398 reviews

    “The store was so neat I got my passport stamped I’m so happy ! I got a piece they didn’t have in pa store so I got it here ! The staff was so nice ! What an amazing staff you made my husband very happy !”

  3. 133-33 39th Ave, Queens NY 11354

    4.9 Superb 150 reviews

    “Loved our experience here! Had zero prior knowledge of strollers, and needed one in the coming days before baby arrives. Not only do they take the time to explain all the different products, they were patient with us when we were going back and forth between brands. Plus side is they are great with communicating on your order and not shy with letting you know about ongoing deals! Thank you Kyle and Eunice, highly recommend Queens Baby!”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 2289 Broadway, New York NY 10024

    4.7 Superb 313 reviews

    “A great place to just chill and read, have a cup of java, very easy to find what you need!! My favorite store!! Also got to meet my favorite author last night, Douglas Preston!”

  6. 36-12 34th Ave, Queens NY 11106

    4.8 Superb 129 reviews

    “Newtown HQ, you have my heart”

  7. 30 Mall Drive West, Jersey City NJ 07302

    4.5 Superb 622 reviews

    “My boyfriend and I had the best time at Rumi's! Even though it was so busy because it was Valentine's day, Miles was extremely attentive and made the best recommendations! Would highly recommend Rumi's as a great date spot”

  8. 140 Lawrence St, Hackensack NJ 07601

    4.8 Superb 140 reviews

    “Great store very friendly staff, great displays and a dangerous amount of products(gunpla and more). The inventory was better then I was expecting, thank you guys for making my trip out a great one I'll be down again soon.”

  9. 30 Rockefeller Plaza, New York NY 10111

    4.5 Superb 545 reviews

    “FAO Schwarz was a nice toy store. It is large and well organized, and the staff is friendly and helpful. We went here for the Jellycat Diner, and I have to say that it was very fun and cool. However, if you want to experience it you need to make a reservation a month or two in advance. Also, there may be a line to get in as we experienced, so just keep that in mind when planning a visit here. A negative is that it can get quite crowded inside, but other than that there isn’t too much to complain about. I would say it is worth a visit if you are in New York and love toy stores, or are especially a fan of Jellycats.”

  10. 11 E 33rd St, New York NY 10016

    4.7 Superb 249 reviews

    “Love to go there - amazing selection - but you have to understand the experience. It contains a HUGE selection of games, and RPG books. Might be the most in NY State outside of the huge Millennium games up in Rochester. I've found items that have been out of print for years, or had small production runs. BUT... Stacked in huge shelves that stretch from floor to ceiling. It takes a while to read through everything! With tiny aisles that barely have room for one person to walk down. If you're claustrophobic, be warned! It's almost all at MSRP. Not a place to get a bargain or a deal, generally (that said, they do have a bargain shelf at the back of the store. Right hand aisle, left side all the way back).”

  11. 761 Metropolitan Ave, Brooklyn NY 11211

    4.8 Superb 164 reviews

    “the most special little pocket of a craft store i had ever hoped to find. forget michael's, artist & craftsman supply has an immense variety of what you need to make art, and you'll be supporting small business! i went in just for some spools of embroidery thread, and not only did they have a huge spectrum of colors, but i must have left with two armfuls of craft supplies - as someone who loves to always be creating new things, that's how i know I'll be coming back forever!!”

  12. 75 Rockefeller Plaza, New York NY 10019

    4.6 Superb 283 reviews

    “I love this place. I visited quite often. It is a small store but lots to see and buy. Little girls love this place. There are a few things for the boys to do. There is a basketball hoop on the main floor and a train set downstairs close to the restaurant. As for the restaurants in the store, it is phenomenal. The food was delicious. I highly recommend a visit when in New York City. The photos are from my most recent visit (7/10/26)”

  13. 1449 Broadway, Brooklyn NY 11221

    4.8 Superb 134 reviews

    “My fav type of craft shop; hold the frills, has all the goods w/ crafty community members at the counter who are excited to help u bring your project to fruition. Will be returning! Got my eye on the little origami kits at least hehe look so fun”

  14. 840 7th Ave, New York NY 10019

    4.9 Superb 131 reviews

    “Great gift shop, has all the regular stuff you’d want to find, but the prices are fair, and the staff are very friendly and kind. We even got a holiday gift of a free magnet. Kevin who I believe is the owner is super nice and definitely deserves the credit!”

  15. 200 5th Ave, New York NY 10010

    4.5 Superb 272 reviews

    “Beautiful store! Everything was clean, and organized the staff was very kind and friendly. The kids had so much fun, especially at the Build a Minifigure station where you can build 3 minifigures for $9.99. They loved choosing all the different parts and putting them together. It's a lovely place for kids. Mine didn't want to leave and wanted to take half the store home. Definitely worth stopping by if you're in the area.”

  16. 36-12 Main St, Flushing NY 11354

    4.8 Superb 78 reviews

    “Went here a few months ago and was blown away by the spaciousness! Definitely more expensive than the other arcades and be prepared to spend more money. However, the merch and plushies are official and licensed, as far as I know this is the only arcade in flushing that does not have bootlegs so that may explain the higher price tag. I will say, I really liked the Lunar New Year promo they had and they should definitely have similar events more often to offset the difficulty and high cost-but at the same time, it's still skill and luck based!Machines are definitely harder, but ask employees for help! The last time we went, we were trying to win a derpy looking dinosaur, and it was very difficult (claw was too weak and plushie was very big and chubby) and the worker helped us reposition. The app did glitch and take away 2 tries for us that we weren't able to play, but the same worker helped us (I never got her name but she had glasses!). She was very encouraging and sweet and helped us win it!”

  17. 390 Hackensack Ave, Hackensack NJ 07601

    4.5 Superb 237 reviews

    “The cashier was super friendly and super helpful! She gave a simple and clear directions for the book I was looking for. The store is super clean and the little hand written blurbs about certain books are a great window into what the books are about. Great place to go book shopping!”

  18. 200 W 40th St, New York NY 10018

    4.6 Superb 208 reviews

    “It was a great experience as the cashier and everyone in the store was very friendly and chill and the wide amount of comics and manga's, toys, and others is just great and I'm happy on my Asuka soryu figure. Great experience defiantly recommend!”

  19. 5203 Bergenline Ave, West New York NJ 07093

    4.7 Superb 103 reviews

    “A community staple that constantly surprises with the stock and inventory they have for some harder to find collectibles/physical copies of games old and new. Shoutout Mr. Yoo!!”

  20. 1178 Lexington Ave, New York NY 10028

    4.8 Superb 104 reviews

    “10/10 experience the selection is wide and unique for the small space. You can find toys for all ages in there at a decent price! Plus I was being indecisive over a fidget toy and they let me open and and play with them after asking of course! They even tried it out themselves 😆 I also found some good needoh type of squishies in here got a hyland cow for 4 dollars and my fidget spinner for 8! You can beat that right now at all. My daughter got 2 sensory toys as well and she was very happy about it. Definitely recommend this shop to everyone and can't wait to come back on my next trip to the city.”

  21. 133-18 39th Ave, Flushing NY 11354

    4.6 Superb 123 reviews

    “Awesome place , definitely recommend going for more than one visit 2026:great store i really enjoy coming here i vist twice a week to see what they have in stock , definitely recommend”

  22. 133 W Broadway, New York NY 10013

    4.5 Superb 186 reviews

    “Yesterday was my son’s birthday party and I thought I ordered the balloons- turns out I didn’t. I called the balloon saloon an hour before the party in a panic. There was a rushed charge, but the Balloon Saloon worked fast, took the order, blew up the balloons and delivered to Chelsea in 45 mins. Thank you for your excellent products, customer service and hustle. I will be a customer for life. Thanks for saving a mom’s butt :)”

  23. 3769 Junction Blvd, Corona NY 11368

    4.5 Superb 135 reviews

    “It was a pleasure to visit this place. The owner and I have had a relationship for more than 30 years, and he is truly the best technician. He always knows exactly what I need, and most importantly, he is very honest with his customers. His integrity and expertise make every visit a great experience. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for reliable service!”

  24. 60 West St Unit 102, Brooklyn NY 11222

    4.7 Superb 96 reviews

    “i freaking love this place. really great place to buy last minute gifts or when you need a little treat after a long week. i love taking visitors here too. i’ll never forget when i asked if they sold those blind box cat hats & they didn’t have them on display at the time, but they brought them out from the back for me :)”

  25. 1540 Broadway, New York NY 10036

    4.3 Superb 427 reviews

    “If your a Disney fan or your kids have a buzzing stop here in a lighting speed. To tell the story to your kids after their get their toys. As their one is a magic experience you can not miss. Lovely things to see And get. For yourself or family.”

  26. 84 W 120th St, New York NY 10027

    4.8 Superb 89 reviews

    “Sometimes you don’t need endless choices or big shiny stores. Sometimes you just want something real. This is one of those authentic local shops that truly deserves support. It’s a neighborhood staple with heart, character, and a genuine purpose behind it. You can feel that this place matters — not just for business, but for the community. And if you’re shopping for kids? You’re in the right place. They have more than enough toys to make little faces light up. Highly recommended if you value authenticity over hype and want your purchase to actually mean something.”

  27. 42-11 Broadway, Astoria NY 11103

    4.5 Superb 116 reviews

    “I love this place The workers are amazing especially the ones that work on Fridays Amazing people good vibes inside the store feels like a community together always have product with amazing prices . Thank you !”

  28. 832 Broadway, New York NY 10003

    4.5 Superb 207 reviews

    “The staff here are incredibly kind and knowledgeable about the specifics, and give genuinely great recommendations. Michelle in particular was really good at finding tailored recommendations for us and giving us substantive thoughts on science fiction-ey comics, and is very well-read! Even if you’re not into comics, it’s worth coming in here and asking the staff about comics, and buying something to support an interesting business and team of people.”

  29. 45 Rockefeller Plaza, New York NY 10112

    4.5 Superb 83 reviews

    “There was a long line to get in, but it moved fairly quickly. Inside, it was crowded and chaotic, but as you’d expect, since it’s a place for kids, it’s normal for them to be fascinated and excited. The prices were pretty high. In any case, the staff was always very friendly, and we were able to create our own personalized bear, too.”

  30. 139 Division St, New York NY 10002

    4.9 Superb 36 reviews

    • Today 11AM – 9PM

    “Biggie's is great! The owners are super lovely and run it themselves. Their dog, Biggie, is super cute. Often there's people playing chess outside- it's pretty rad. Inside is a vintage lovers paradise, or more specifically, a vintage smokers dream. They specialize in refurbishing old lighters, ash trays, and smoking sets. Trust me, they're awesome. If you're not a smoker, they have old magazines, game sets, and old-style soda. If you'd like to become a smoker but are scared, they have candy cigarettes. Sick! Anyway, I like to pop by whenever I'm in the neighborhood. You should pop in, too.”

  31. 188 Eckford St, Brooklyn NY 11222

    4.5 Superb 84 reviews

    “Amazed!. I was coming home from work and decided to stop by. I am starting my Dominican baseball baseball card collection and they had a ton . the staff was amazing”

Advertisement

Toy Stores in nearby cities