Toy Stores in New York, NY

30 locations found near New York

“The store was so neat I got my passport stamped I’m so happy ! I got a piece they didn’t have in pa store so I got it here ! The staff was so nice ! What an amazing staff you made my husband very happy !”

4.8 Superb398 Reviews

“A great place to just chill and read, have a cup of java, very easy to find what you need!! My favorite store!!
Also got to meet my favorite author last night, Douglas Preston!”

4.7 Superb313 Reviews

“FAO Schwarz was a nice toy store. It is large and well organized, and the staff is friendly and helpful. We went here for the Jellycat Diner, and I have to say that it was very fun and cool. However, if you want to experience it you need to make a reservation a month or two in advance. Also, there may be a line to get in as we experienced, so just keep that in mind when planning a visit here. A negative is that it can get quite crowded inside, but other than that there isn’t too much to complain about. I would say it is worth a visit if you are in New York and love toy stores, or are especially a fan of Jellycats.”

4.5 Superb545 Reviews

“Love to go there - amazing selection - but you have to understand the experience. It contains a HUGE selection of games, and RPG books. Might be the most in NY State outside of the huge Millennium games up in Rochester. I've found items that have been out of print for years, or had small production runs.
BUT...
Stacked in huge shelves that stretch from floor to ceiling. It takes a while to read through everything! With tiny aisles that barely have room for one person to walk down. If you're claustrophobic, be warned!
It's almost all at MSRP. Not a place to get a bargain or a deal, generally (that said, they do have a bargain shelf at the back of the store. Right hand aisle, left side all the way back).”

4.7 Superb249 Reviews

“I love this place. I visited quite often. It is a small store but lots to see and buy. Little girls love this place. There are a few things for the boys to do. There is a basketball hoop on the main floor and a train set downstairs close to the restaurant. As for the restaurants in the store, it is phenomenal. The food was delicious. I highly recommend a visit when in New York City.

The photos are from my most recent visit (7/10/26)”

4.6 Superb283 Reviews

“Beautiful store! Everything was clean, and organized the staff was very kind and friendly.

The kids had so much fun, especially at the Build a Minifigure station where you can build 3 minifigures for $9.99. They loved choosing all the different parts and putting them together.

It's a lovely place for kids. Mine didn't want to leave and wanted to take half the store home. Definitely worth stopping by if you're in the area.”

4.5 Superb272 Reviews

“Great gift shop, has all the regular stuff you’d want to find, but the prices are fair, and the staff are very friendly and kind.
We even got a holiday gift of a free magnet.
Kevin who I believe is the owner is super nice and definitely deserves the credit!”

4.9 Superb131 Reviews

“It was a great experience as the cashier and everyone in the store was very friendly and chill and the wide amount of comics and manga's, toys, and others is just great and I'm happy on my Asuka soryu figure. Great experience defiantly recommend!”

4.6 Superb208 Reviews

“If your a Disney fan or your kids have a buzzing stop here in a lighting speed.
To tell the story to your kids after their get their toys.
As their one is a magic experience you can not miss.
Lovely things to see And get.
For yourself or family.”

4.3 Superb427 Reviews

“Yesterday was my son’s birthday party and I thought I ordered the balloons- turns out I didn’t. I called the balloon saloon an hour before the party in a panic. There was a rushed charge, but the Balloon Saloon worked fast, took the order, blew up the balloons and delivered to Chelsea in 45 mins. Thank you for your excellent products, customer service and hustle. I will be a customer for life. Thanks for saving a mom’s butt :)”

4.5 Superb186 Reviews

“10/10 experience the selection is wide and unique for the small space. You can find toys for all ages in there at a decent price! Plus I was being indecisive over a fidget toy and they let me open and and play with them after asking of course! They even tried it out themselves 😆 I also found some good needoh type of squishies in here got a hyland cow for 4 dollars and my fidget spinner for 8! You can beat that right now at all. My daughter got 2 sensory toys as well and she was very happy about it. Definitely recommend this shop to everyone and can't wait to come back on my next trip to the city.”

4.8 Superb104 Reviews

“I am writing this review for the online customer service. Out of all the physical and online stores I went ahead and ordered everything I possibly could for my baby from albee baby exclusively. Their good deals, fast shippings, amazing rewards program, and most importantly customer service support was what I liked the most! Elon, the representative, was THE BEST representative ever. He was very knowledgeable, caring, very detailed oriented and he is the main reason I ended up ordering everything from albee baby. He helped me a lot , thank you Elon”

4.3 Superb270 Reviews

“The staff here are incredibly kind and knowledgeable about the specifics, and give genuinely great recommendations. Michelle in particular was really good at finding tailored recommendations for us and giving us substantive thoughts on science fiction-ey comics, and is very well-read!

Even if you’re not into comics, it’s worth coming in here and asking the staff about comics, and buying something to support an interesting business and team of people.”

4.5 Superb207 Reviews

“There was a long line to get in, but it moved fairly quickly. Inside, it was crowded and chaotic, but as you’d expect, since it’s a place for kids, it’s normal for them to be fascinated and excited. The prices were pretty high. In any case, the staff was always very friendly, and we were able to create our own personalized bear, too.”

4.5 Superb83 Reviews

“Sometimes you don’t need endless choices or big shiny stores. Sometimes you just want something real.

This is one of those authentic local shops that truly deserves support. It’s a neighborhood staple with heart, character, and a genuine purpose behind it. You can feel that this place matters — not just for business, but for the community.

And if you’re shopping for kids? You’re in the right place. They have more than enough toys to make little faces light up.

Highly recommended if you value authenticity over hype and want your purchase to actually mean something.”

4.8 Superb89 Reviews

“I was here years before as a tourist and bought some very cute cloths for my niece :) I'm very happy to see your store still existing because it was right when the pandemic hit the city. Wish you guys all the best!!”

4.6 Superb98 Reviews

“Biggie's is great! The owners are super lovely and run it themselves. Their dog, Biggie, is super cute. Often there's people playing chess outside- it's pretty rad.

Inside is a vintage lovers paradise, or more specifically, a vintage smokers dream. They specialize in refurbishing old lighters, ash trays, and smoking sets. Trust me, they're awesome. If you're not a smoker, they have old magazines, game sets, and old-style soda. If you'd like to become a smoker but are scared, they have candy cigarettes. Sick!

Anyway, I like to pop by whenever I'm in the neighborhood. You should pop in, too.”

4.9 Superb36 Reviews

“Very nice toy store with a decent selection. Reminds me very much of S.W Randall in Pittsburgh. Staff are unbelievably friendly and easy going. This place is worth checking out if you are ever in New York.”

4.5 Superb114 Reviews

“My brother and I came here from Chicago and were planning to visit the Empire State Building, and we found this store right next to it. From the moment we walked in, we loved the energy and atmosphere.

A special thank you to Zoila, Juan, and Geo for making our visit so enjoyable. Zoila was incredibly kind and helped me find the perfect gift for my girlfriend. She was patient, friendly, and made the whole experience memorable. Juan was also very welcoming and spent time talking with me while I was waiting for my friends, which I really appreciated.

While I was there, I noticed they also host kids’ parties. It was great to see how much the children were enjoying themselves and how well everything was organized.

Thank you, Zoila, for helping create such a warm and positive environment. I highly recommend this place and will definitely visit again!”

4.2 Good225 Reviews

“Anwar was really kind and lovely! He helped check us out at the counter. He was talking to us about things in the area. He was telling us there was a table where we could open out ateez photocards. He was like he said his name means a light, to which should always keep shining. Hope we can see him again when we go back in a month! Thanks also rest of the staff! I didnt get their names but there were three other employees and were also helpful and kind as well. Thank you all hope you are doing well.”

4.2 Good262 Reviews

“Love this store! It's clean & organized. They have a SUPER employee named Xavier! I didn't even see any other employee in the store this today (4th of July)!”

4.3 Superb75 Reviews

“So many cute figurines!!! Adorable shop that will make you want to buy everything ? Also to the staff/cashier who told me about the choco chiikawa boxes: if you’re reading this, thank youuuuu!!!! I didn’t get Hachiware but still happy with Chiikawa ????”

4.3 Superb81 Reviews

“This small space has a shocking amount of art supplies. Hot glue sticks, foam core boards in several sizes, drawing pads etc. They also carry hula hoops all year. Do you know how hard it is to find a hula hoop in the winter? This place is the greatest. Shop local!”

4.6 Superb84 Reviews

“Most beautiful toy store selling Waldorf and handmade wood toys. Great place to browse brands like Ostheimer, Drewart, etc in person. Helpful staff and friendly vibes!”

4.6 Superb52 Reviews

“we had a fantastic experience here while buying my daughter her first pair of shoes. the owners were so welcoming and warm and monica was so knowledgeable and helpful with finding my daughter the perfect pair. such a gem in the neighborhood!”

4.6 Superb48 Reviews

“I went here in November and it was awesome. They had a cool Lego Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade. They also have a Lego Bluey statue a Lego Statue of Liberty and much more. I will definitely come back here again five stars actually you want six stars I mean, I can’t wait this, but I saying six stars.”

4.1 Good68 Reviews

“I had a great experience ordering a Lava Squish N' Flow for my nephew's birthday from ToyWiz. They're very popular right now, and ToyWiz is the only place that had them in stock at a reasonable place. The first one they sent unfortunately had a manufacturing defect, and all the liquid had leaked out of it. ToyWiz sent a replacement immediately, and they even opened the box to check that the replacement was in good shape, and then resealed it. My nephew thought it was a pretty neat present, and I would definitely order from ToyWiz again!”

4 Good243 Reviews

“It's a little bit pricey, but my kid had a lot of fun. At first, their system accepted my appointment at a private event. We had to wait for two hours until the event finished. My daughter was so disappointed since we came all the way from downtown Brooklyn. The staff apologized for the mixed up nicely, and as a software engineer, I know that technology is not reliable sometimes. So, I decided not to blame the store. Everyone there was so nice, my daughter really enjoyed her craft and said that she wanted to come back next time.But I'd recommend looking into the system issue since it was very disappointing at the beginning.”

4.7 Superb55 Reviews

“When I enquired about Certainly not a Celebrity the staff at Barnes & Noble could not have been more helpful. Their empathy with smiles and laughter was contagious, it was a marvellous experience.”

3.9 Good142 Reviews

“We attended Bluey's House experience with a toddler and I have to say I was really impressed with Camp NYC. So much more than I expected. It was the perfect rainy day/indoor activity. We gave it a lot of Oooohs and Aaaahs. From the whole tour concept to the perfect amount of activities to keep your little ones interested and not over-stimulated, I would give it a 10-Star rating if possible. Kudos to the friendly employees as well!”

3.9 Good144 Reviews