“First time in person, have ordered online and had them deliver. Very clean and fresh, staff super knowledgeable and friendly. Great service and selection. Can't wait for their Middletown store to open !!!”
“We stopped into Dutch Hill Farm Market and Meat Shoppe to pick up steaks for Father’s Day and left with so much more than just dinner—we found our new go-to butcher! We had the pleasure of meeting (who we believe was) the owner, who was incredibly warm, welcoming, and knowledgeable. He walked us through the different cuts and recommended the Wagyu New York strip and spinalis—both were absolutely next level. Everyone was raving. The meat was insanely tender—like butter! We also tried the teriyaki pineapple sausage, and it was divine. From the quality of the meat to the customer service, this place is top tier. Can’t wait to come back!”
9:30AM - 5:30PM
40 Steiner Ave, Neptune City
Butchers
“Had the cheesesteak and it was full of flavor and was just great. Definitely one of the best in NJ and Philly. Will definitely be visiting regularly to get this particular sandwich”
9AM - 6:30PM
25 Main St, Asbury Park
Butchers
“Very small but efficient basic meat market. They do have fish but an extremely limited selection and it's frozen. They do have good fresh meat at reasonable prices and special meat packages that are budget friendly. The meat is good. Service is very good.”
“Fabulous ALWAYS! The employees ALL gems, welcoming, friendly helpful and quick. The quality of meat is outstanding! Breads, premade foods,bakery treats sooo good! The sandwiches and subs are to die for. You get your money's worth here and in these times it feels good to know you get what you pay for. The shop itself is packed with goodies but doesn't feel overcrowded. Busy place but service is fast and if you have to wait it's never too long!”
“Old Tyme Butcher is the kind of place you don’t come across often anymore. Super welcoming every time you walk in, and you can tell they genuinely care about what they’re selling. The steak selection is unreal — great cuts, always fresh, and you can taste the difference. This one speaks for itself. Easily our favorite spot when we want something done right”