American Thrift Store in Passaic offers a diverse shopping experience with a wide range of vintage and brand-name items at affordable prices. Customers appreciate the large selection of clothing, accessories, household goods, and furniture, making it a popular destination for families and thrift enthusiasts. The store is well-organized, and the cashiers are noted for their friendliness, contributing to a positive atmosphere. However, some reviews express concerns about the rising prices of certain items, which some believe do not reflect their used condition. This has led to disappointment among long-time shoppers who feel the store has changed due to gentrification. While there are enjoyable finds, there are also reports of items being overpriced, causing frustration among bargain-hunters. Customer service experiences vary, with some praising the staff's friendliness while others report rudeness from floor associates. Instances of uncomfortable interactions and complaints about staff behavior have been highlighted, creating a mixed atmosphere for shoppers. Despite these issues, many customers still find unique treasures and enjoy the store's heart, attributed to the hardworking owners. Overall, American Thrift Store remains a place for daily discoveries, but with some areas needing attention to enhance the shopping experience.
Quite a shopping experience! Give yourself plenty of time to shop. So much to see. Well organized, great variety of items.
August 2026
I Excellent prices on this gorgeous, elegant lamp for $7.99 and this Conair curling iron with air blower for $3.99!
July 2026
Found a variety of items with good prices! You must be patient & look. Of course, some items are pricier than others but overall, there’s options. No complaints on my end. Bought Madewell, Carhartt, Ralph Lauren, hokas, jewelry for less than $40
