Used, Vintage & Consignment near Stirling, NJ

“Love the selection , much with tags still on. I always do really well , great price points. Good sales, really lovely owner Carol and attentive staff Diane , I like to make a visit when i am nearby at Shrine of St Joseph , I always leave a happy, blessed customer and then stop at Biaggios for a delish italian lunch or sweet treat and cappucino/espresso”

“Hands down the best consignment shop I’ve ever visited. The selection is incredibly curated—high-quality, authentic pieces that feel more like a luxury boutique than a resale store. You can tell real care goes into what they accept and display.

The staff is knowledgeable, honest, and genuinely helpful without being pushy. Prices are fair, transparent, and reflect the quality of the items. Whether you’re buying or consigning, the process is smooth and professional.

If you appreciate style, craftsmanship, and a great shopping experience, this place is a must. I’ll definitely be back.”

“New start is such a great cute store! My sister and I went a few weeks ago and spoke with Thomas who was extremely kind and knowledgeable. We had a great experience and are excited to go again soon!!”

“Best thrift store in NJ as far as I can tell! Incredibly well curated selection with great vintage pieces. The owner Victor was incredibly kind and was an absolute pleasure to chat with! Go for the hidden gems and stay for the stories! 11/10 recommend!”

“I love consignment and thrift shopping for designer and high end brands. Nothing beats the thrill of finding an unexpected label for a low price.
I also enjoy traveling to new places and exploring which is exactly what I did on my first visit to Erby’s Elite Repeat.
I took a solo drive from 1 1/2 hours away to visit a well known online resale retailer’s brick and mortar store, Short Hills Mall and other boutiques/ consignment/ thrift stores in the immediate vicinity.
Erby’s was my favorite by far. Large store, well stocked and thoughtfully arranged. Lots of different brands and great prices. I talked with the owner while I shopped and she was so nice and personable.
I spied a shoe that caught my eye and upon inspection realized they were Sneex.
I can not wear heels which bothers me, since so many outfits look 1,000 times better with them.
I had heard about this brand that was supposed to be so comfortable and not feel like heels at all.
I was hesitant to purchase on-line ( never saw them in a store) due to possible issues finding the correct size, high possibility I would still find them unwearable, high price point (@$550 at the time) and a charge for returns.
So I was very excited they were my normal size and I was able to see them in person and try them on.
Beautiful, high quality and they were comfortable!
Did I mention they were brand new!!!!! Not a mark on them, including the bottoms!! Erby’s price was amazing and the owner gave me an even greater deal!
My visit to Erby’s Elite Repeat was the highlight of my 12 hour shopping trip.
Highly recommend.
Definitely returning.”

“Love this place. I've found so many gems here. Besides clothes, I've found many books I've loved and added to my collection. Liz and Mike are the best!!”

“Amazing vintage store that is filled with vintage treasures. Their assortment of coats, sweaters, jewelry and more is incredible. I have never seen such an incredible selection of sequined jackets and tops ever. Their selection of wool is also impressive. Plus the owner is very kind, friendly and passionate about vintage!Be sure to also check out their Etsy for additional options not available in store. If you love vintage then definitely save this place and visit when you have time! You will not be disappointed.”

“Like any great consignment or vintage shop, if you do a little digging, you are going to find a few gems. The Vested Interest is probably one of the most organized shops I've visited, so the digging isn't too intense and the gems are really not too hard to find. Need a sweater? Well, go to the sweater section. Shoes? All in one place. Blazers, coats, outerwear? All separated so even sifting between different kinds of jackets isn't tough. You get the point. AND on top of all of that, it is very well sorted between sizes. My mom comes here often and has gotten a few great pieces for herself and as gifts over the years. And on my last trip I walked away with two beautiful coats! One was Jones New York and still had the original tags for $400.... I walked out with it for $80. The woman working there when I stopped in was super helpful, gave me some opinions when I asked for them and was very kind. When I didn't ask for any help, she just let me look around and shop without feeling rushed. Excited to pop back in every once and awhile! If you are looking for any gifts for the holidays, I definitely recommend shopping this great small second hand shop.”

“My mom and I visited today. It was fantastic. The clothes and household items are great quality and at good prices. The owner was very kind as well. We both got many nice things. Will return again soon.”

“Over the past 2-3 years I have had great experience bringing beautiful crystal, china, etc. on consignment to Home Again, and was always welcome. 99% would sell well. If something was below the shop standard they simply mentioned it and I kept it for donation. I have enjoyed going to also get out of my Covid zone last year! My time with Kathy has always been a very positive experience. Recently I had 5 boxes but was not sure it was up to their standard, I emailed Kathy all the item pictures, she thanked me but they were not to standard as I had guessed, I did not have to drive there. I dropped the content to the VNA sale in FarHills for Morristown Medical Center. Kathy told me she was looking forward when I would go again. Always a pleasant positive experience with anyone at the counter!”

“A beautiful store with beautiful people unique pieces at extremely affordable prices come in it will never disappoint a must see in Madison and at the other location in Towako”

“Love this place and the Owner Elena is super friendly and fun the items she sells are good quality and authentic would definitely shop hear again as the inventory is always changing and their are many unique peices”

“My mom and I stopped by today and had the best time. The owner, Gabby is warm and welcoming. She has the prettiest collection of clothing! You can really tell she takes care to cultivate a fun experience,,. We’ll definitely be back!”

“The store in South Plainfield is generally clean and organized. I have not had many interactions with staff members, except at the checkout line. Maybe a few workers have English as their second language.

I love looking at all the items. It gets crowded on 50% off sale days, but that is to be expected.

Some clothes are brand new, with their tags still on! Be careful of prices and check the color of the tags to see if they are on sale that day. Warning - you cannot purchase an item if it doesn't have a tag. Make sure you check all your items for rips or stains, broken zippers, etc.”