Jewelry Stores near West Caldwell, NJ

30 locations found near West Caldwell

“I bought my first piece of jewelry for my girlfriend in 1980 from Eleanor then onto all my jewelry from the Willowbrook Mall ,, then as they moved to Caldwell, we continue to use them, including my girlfriend turned into my wife’s wedding band and now my son just bought his girlfriend a wedding ban from Eleanor as well. Full circle from 1980 to 2025…. still great service and great prices. !”

5 Superb50 Reviews

“I had an outstanding experience at West Essex Jewelers. I brought in a watch with a broken band, and not only did they repair it, but they also crafted a brand-new band that fits perfectly and looks even better than the original. The quality of the workmanship is exceptional, and the attention to detail really shows.
The staff was knowledgeable, professional, and took the time to explain my options. It's clear that they take pride in their craftsmanship and genuinely care about customer satisfaction.

If you're looking for expert jewelry or watch repair, I highly recommend this shop. Thanks a million for the amazing work! Your excellent service, and commitment to quality have earned a customer for life!”

5 Superb88 Reviews

“Rick made a beutiful custom pendant necklace for me . Kept me informed all through the process . Craftsmanship was exceptional and customer service is second to none . Highly recommend !”

5 Superb240 Reviews

“Michael restored my mother's watch and was so helpful in showing me how to maintain it, that I knew I wanted to work with him to create a custom piece of jewelry. Michael definitely understood my vision and created exactly what I wanted. The jewelry is beautifully made and given the work and materials, I felt it was very fairly priced. From a big project to a small one, I would absolutely trust Michael.”

5 Superb172 Reviews

“Went for an engagement ring and my sales rep was Jenny! Jenny was awesome in every way imaginable. Super friendly helpful. Made the whole experience very smooth and easy. Cannot recommend them enough. They help you through every step of the process provide all kinds of support and work with your budget as well. The final product will blow you away!!”

5 Superb226 Reviews

“They saved us in a last minute request! The best experience I’ve ever had with a jeweler. Thank you Jeffrey and your shop Angels Faviola and Ariel. We had a last minute need for wedding bands and they delivered in less than hr. My fiance and I suffered a family loss and decided last minute to continue with the wedding, except we didn’t have the wedding bands! I gave it a try and they helped us an hr before closing time. Thank you again Jeffrey, Ariel and Faviola for this and for your kind words and compassion.”

4.9 Superb293 Reviews

“Devin and the team were amazing. They were attentive, professional and helpful in answering my questions. I needed to resize my engagement ring in anticipation of my wedding. They were able to get me an appointment right away and the resizing was done in a very short amount of time (4 hours). Highly recommend Devin and the team! The customer service was superb.”

5 Superb117 Reviews

“From the moment you’re buzzed in through the security door through the personalized service and attention to the beautiful designs of their jewelry, you walk out feeling richer then you walked in.
Thank you to Richard and his team at West Jewelry.”

5 Superb141 Reviews

“I went into Gerlach to have a necklace chain repaired. The staff was so kind and were able to fix my necklace very quickly. After such amazing service I was completely surprised that they did not charge me at all and just were happy to help me. I will definitely be returning to Gerlach. The jewelry on display was beautiful, unique pieces (a lot from estates) and were very reasonably priced. Highly recommend this place!”

5 Superb91 Reviews

“Nothing but the best of designers, personal service and value. Although I’ve moved, Fredrick’s is my favorite and only place to buy jewelry!!”

5 Superb146 Reviews

“A 40+ year customer of both Morristown & New Providence stores. Have always been pleased with the knowledgeable staff & timely service. Just had my 37 yr old sapphire & diamond engagement ring repaired and it looks like it did the first time I wore it...sparkling & beautiful. Thank you Caitlin & jewelers!”

5 Superb108 Reviews

“John and his team helped us so much related to our wedding and we are very grateful! He created my engagement ring and my wedding band and clearly is an expert at all things related to jewelry design, creation, and repair. He also helped repair a broken pearl necklace two weeks before my wedding, and designed my brother and his wife's wedding bands. All of his work is gorgeous.”

5 Superb138 Reviews

“I’ve been working with Alex at Yanina for a couple of years now, and I genuinely can’t say enough good things. Whether I’m buying something new, bringing in old pieces to redesign, or just getting a simple resizing job done, every single time the work is beautiful and the experience is delightful.

I feel so lucky I found them. Their collection is beyond stunning, and if you have something custom in mind, they’ll bring it to life better than you could have imagined. Alex is truly amazing!!

. . , But be warned: if you walk in, you’ll likely walk out a lot more sparkly! I always do!!”

5 Superb132 Reviews

“Great service all around, staff was very friendly. I was running late trying to get there before they closed and they waited for me! A lot of transparency, fair pricing and I sold gold to them as well. Definitely my go to place moving forward. Thank you again!”

4.9 Superb144 Reviews

“Very good service and great work. I used them for a custom grill and to repair a broken gold chain. Highly recommend.
You have the option of purchasing premade jewelry or working with the staff to create custom pieces. Staff is very friendly and cooperative and they do beautiful work.”

4.9 Superb141 Reviews

“Lou’s Jeweler’s is a charming old fashioned family run jewelry store owned by Lou and Rita. I was recently introduced to them after learning about their reasonable watch battery prices and quick turn around time - and I’m so glad I was.

Lou replaced several batteries in both men’s and women’s watches and even repaired two men’s watches that other jewelers had told me were beyond fixing. I had even sent one back to the manufacturer who claimed it was repaired - but still did t work. Lou fixed it without a problem. Before doing any work, he carefully explained what needed to be done and provided clear pricing, which I truly appreciated.

I also brought in a very old cross pendant that belonged to my husband’s grandmother. My husband had worn it his entire life until the top clasp broke off over 35 years ago. We had been told by multiple jewelers it couldn’t be repaired but I always kept it in my jewelry box. Lou restored it beautifully and I was able to surprise my husband with it on his 64th birthday. It was an incredibly meaningful gift made possible by Lou’s skill.

In addition. Lou created a replica of a unique gold Turkish ring that my husband’s grandmother had given me over 35 years ago. Despite having limited time before Christmas. he crafted a perfect copy for our daughter. He even suggested putting both rings in a box under the tree to see if she could tell them apart - she couldn’t! It was such a special moment.

Lou has repaired, shortened and lengthened gold bracelets, fixed watch bands, and we have even purchased jewelry from their store. Lou and Rita truly take pride in their craftsmanship and customer service. Beyond jewelry and watches, they can custom make just about anything, offer ear piercing, and even repair all types of clocks - including cuckoo clocks.

If you are looking for skill, honesty and heartfelt service, Lou’s Jewelers is exceptional.”

5 Superb103 Reviews

“Purchased many beautiful pieces of jewelry and had many custom diamond pieces made ….also purchased many watches from Robert .. it is a family owned business they are the best and great Customer service !!!!!!
They are my go to for everything !”

5 Superb109 Reviews

“Great experience! The staff was friendly and helpful, the jewelry selection was beautiful, and the quality was excellent. Prices felt fair, and I never felt rushed or pressured. I’ll definitely be back and highly recommend this store.”

4.9 Superb93 Reviews

“Mohamed from London Jewelers was great to work with. He was very knowledgeable, helpful, and honest from the beginning. There's no doubt we'll be going back to him for any future purchases. It was a great experience from start to finish.”

4.8 Superb154 Reviews

“I have to say Yalina and Isabella are GREAT!
Awesome customers service and gave me great ideas for my custom earrings.
Will definitely be back to get my wife and daugther jewelry from these ladies.”

4.8 Superb166 Reviews

“I love this jewelry shop, it’s my go to for a special event. They have everything from studs to drop earrings to bracelets. Stop by for something unique and special. Great service!”

4.9 Superb91 Reviews

“The best jewelers ever! A staple in the community I only trust them for all my needs ,buying, selling, repairs. Walter is fabulous the customer service sets the “gold” standard. Please visit Walter Bauman Jewelers you will not be sorry. Thank you for such great service and Quality!”

4.9 Superb127 Reviews

“Brianna B had excellent service, she help my friend who was terrified of piercings get through her experience and now she love her thirds! Would definitely come back to her!”

4.8 Superb126 Reviews

“Very professional these guys!!! They made my 6yr old earrings brand new all over..couldn't even wear them for mths now I'm shining!!Thanks Brick City U guys Rock?”

4.8 Superb125 Reviews

“For over 15 years, my family and I have trusted only one jeweler, and I truly can’t recommend him enough. Matthew’s craftsmanship, creativity, honesty, and pricing are unmatched. Recently, he transformed my old wedding rings into the most gorgeous bracelet and necklaces, and I was blown away by how beautifully everything turned out.

He is incredibly easy to work with, listens to exactly what you want, and somehow always comes up with even better ideas. His custom pieces are absolutely stunning, and his prices are more than fair for the quality and care he puts into every piece.

It’s rare to find someone this talented, trustworthy, and consistent for over a decade. I wouldn’t go anywhere else.”

4.9 Superb67 Reviews

“Carla was a huge help! She helped me get what I wanted and showed me the different prices of the gold and pieces they have! 10/10 service! Recommend everyone get their jewelry here!”

5 Superb63 Reviews

“I would definitely recommend State Gold Buyers to family and friends when ever I am in a bad situation needing money this is the number one place to come to they are very reasonable and passionate about helping people in bad situations. Thank you so much!!!”

5 Superb55 Reviews

“Beautiful quality rings. Excatly as described. I had to have both resized larger. They completed this with ease, high quality and did not skimp or choose to rip off a customer. I will be buying from them again!”

4.8 Superb84 Reviews

“Thank you Roseanne at Willowbrook Mall in Wayne. It was an absolute pleasure meeting you! Roseanne was incredibly helpful in guiding me toward the perfect memorable piece of jewelry. I highly recommend her to anyone looking for outstanding service and expert advice when selecting something truly special.”

4.7 Superb195 Reviews

“This was my first time shopping here, and went to both number #1 I couldn’t be happier. Neil was so kind and attentive, answering all my questions and helping me find the perfect diamond earrings. The quality is excellent, the prices were fair, and you can tell this family-owned business truly cares about their customers. They worked with my budget and made the whole experience a pleasure. Highly recommend!”

5 Superb49 Reviews